I will admit I have not read the entire thread, but the electrons are free and you can ignore my post...
My wife and I have been campers since childhood. Our kids grew up in primitive camp with our blackpowder activities. Now that the kids are grown, my wife and I are accomplished car campers.
But hunting started to horn in on plans and equipment. In short, we weighed the idea of a new wall tent setup, or a trailer. $$$ more for the trailer, but it won, and I think it was a good decision. We used it for elk camp this year - was great, and we got our elk as a bonus. We bought it in late July, and by the end of elk camp had been in it almost 30 nites. On the other hand, it has been at the dealer for warranty service just about as much as we have had it here at the house.
Right now, prices are stupid high - instead of negotiating, sellers just smile. Low inventory, high demand, full retail. Used is a good deal, because these things really depreciate once they drive off the lot. And if I was Amish, I'd be really pissed that "Amish Craftsmanship" is a selling point.
But for the two of us, our 20' rig has made for good times in the woods, fun time on the river, a great trip to see grandkids, and a good elk hunt. I try to ignore the little things that fail, since once that's all done I'll have a trailer that is the way I like it (I'm replacing and upgrading some things, just for fun if nothing else).
One point to keep in mind - cold weather. Only a subset of trailers are fit for winter use - ours had to be winterized before we went hunting, so we still had to use a latrine and water like we were camping. If you want to be able to use it for late season hunting, you need to shop a model that is fit for winter. And plan on a generator, and back that up with solar panels.
Oh well, I rambled. Easier to have just had you come over, have a beer, and talk it over. I'm sure there's plenty of info on this thread.