Gerald Martin
Well-known member
- Joined
- Jul 3, 2009
- Messages
- 9,313
No disagreement in your scenario either.
To be clear i note a striking difference between avoiding civilians and targetting them. And i dont fall victim to thinking israel shouldnt return fire or act in an act of preservation.
Just pointing out that us becoming occupiers to the detriment of our young men and checkbook has yielded very poor returns.
I have no disagreement with any of this. ^^^^
It’s an ugly situation that I pray we don’t get directly involved in. I do support supplying Israel with what they need for self-preservation.
I have no doubts that there are many instances where uninvolved civilians were mistakenly or carelessly targeted and killed. However, it seems ironic and privileged for Americans to criticize Israeli defense forces for doing what they deem necessary to protect themselves when Americans killed more innocent Germans in one firebombing raid over Dresden than Israel has killed total combatants and civilians in Gaza in months. That doesn’t even acknowledge the hundreds of thousands of other civilians killed in Germany and firebombing Japanese cities.
Our government and military did what they determined necessary to do in preservation of democracy and stopping the Axis powers.
Are we in position to judge a country and people whose current national existence was born in the ashes of 6 million cremated innocents and met with the vow of destruction from governments and religious militants that surrounded them?
Last edited:


