I would suggest whatever boot you feel comfortable with. I personally like the lace up because I never know what terrain I am hiking in...or out of. Generally speaking, I can intend to hunt and follow game trails, and take the path of least resistance, but when it comes to cutting the distance to cut off an elk and get to where he is going to be, all bets are off. I use a higher lace up boot and coat it in a high quality waterproofing so that I can hunt any terrain, high or low, wet or dry. The biggest thing is to keep your feet comfortable. If you are on an extended hunt, the first or second day with a blister can make or break the rest of your hunting experience. I would also recommend taking some moleskin,. If you get a blister this will help. I have also used Duct tape. I know it sounds crazy, but I take a roll of duct tape on every hunt. There are many uses for it!