I tend to like the squaring. It gives the people who have applied year after year with a better probability of drawing a tag, while giving the low point holder a shot at drawing a coveted tag. I have been much luckier than I should have been in Nevada.
I somehow always draw at least tag in Nevada (even if it's just a doe tag), but never more than two. The thrill every year is the chance your name is called for one of the sheep tags, mountain goat, bear, PIW or Silver State, or your #1 swing for the fences type hunt.
Even without squaring people who have applied for many years without drawing see their odds improving. With squaring, it happens much more slowly.
Let’s say you apply this year, and I started applying 5 years ago. You have zero points, and I have 5.
Year 1 squared. unsquared
You 1 chance. 1 chance
Me 26 chances. 6 chances
3.8% my odds. 17% my odds
Year 2 squared. Unsquared
You 2 chances. 2 chances
Me 37 chances. 7 chances
5.4% my odds. 29%my odds
Year 3 squared Unsquared
5 chances. 3 chances
50 chances 8 chances
10% my odds. 38% my odds
year 4 squared. Unsquared
10 chances 4 chances
65 chances 9 chances
15% my odds 44% my odds
Year 5 squared. Unsquared
17 chances. 5 chances
82 chances. 10 chances
21% my odds 50 % my odds
Lets jump to year 20 and say your son starts applying.
year 20 squared. Unsquared
Son. 1 chance. 1 chance
You 362 chances. 20 chances
Me 626 chances 26 chances
Son .16% my odds. 3.8% my odds
You 58% my odds. 77% my odds
Most people can draw doe tags in their home state. Nots very many of us are using a doe deer tag(along with all the fuel) to justify the price of out of state applications.
IF there is an out of state tag that really interests you, and YOU CAN EXPECT TO DRAW IN THE FUTURE(not the case for most tags in NV), AND you can frequently draw antlerless tags in the same unit FOR THE SAME GENERAL TIME OF YEAR, then that’s a very useful tactic for learning a unit. If the doe tag is at a different time of year, then going once or twice to learn the road is about as much usefulness as you’ll get out of it.