Wyoming Girl, 12, Stuns With One-Shot Kill From 600 Yards To Bag Huge Elk

It’s a great shot. I read the article. That’s wide open country up there.

I wonder how many times she practiced the shot before? Or is she like my kids. Go to the range once or twice all summer. Then have a deer or elk standing past distances that they did not practice? My kids have been grumpy with me when I’ve had to say nope to far. Should have practiced more.
 
Am I the only one feeling a bit disgusted by this article? It isn't so much the fact of a 600 yard shot, that is for a different discussion, but by the fact that the article highlights it being 600 yards. Why not just remove the range from the story? Shooting 600 yards takes practice and solid knowledge of the ballistics of your rifle and ammo and I'm not a fan of the article promoting the shot distance as a highlight of the event. She may be able to do it but does this make others now think they can when they shouldn't be?

There is also this from the article:
1764603874420.png

Why are you only practicing to 500 yards but then in the field taking a 600 yard shot? The ballistics are significantly different between those two ranges and its another MOA into your on target shot variance.
 
seeth07 said:
Am I the only one feeling a bit disgusted by this article? It isn't so much the fact of a 600 yard shot, that is for a different discussion, but by the fact that the article highlights it being 600 yards. Why not just remove the range from the story? Shooting 600 yards takes practice and solid knowledge of the ballistics of your rifle and ammo and I'm not a fan of the article promoting the shot distance as a highlight of the event. She may be able to do it but does this make others now think they can when they shouldn't be?

There is also this from the article:
View attachment 394556

Why are you only practicing to 500 yards but then in the field taking a 600 yard shot? The ballistics are significantly different between those two ranges and its another MOA into your on target shot variance.
Click to expand...
One click difference wasn't significant...
 
seeth07 said:
Am I the only one feeling a bit disgusted by this article? It isn't so much the fact of a 600 yard shot, that is for a different discussion, but by the fact that the article highlights it being 600 yards. Why not just remove the range from the story? Shooting 600 yards takes practice and solid knowledge of the ballistics of your rifle and ammo and I'm not a fan of the article promoting the shot distance as a highlight of the event. She may be able to do it but does this make others now think they can when they shouldn't be?

There is also this from the article:
View attachment 394556

Why are you only practicing to 500 yards but then in the field taking a 600 yard shot? The ballistics are significantly different between those two ranges and its another MOA into your on target shot variance.
Click to expand...
Just because you can't make the shot doesn't mean others can't
 
dsotm said:
Just because you can't make the shot doesn't mean others can't
Click to expand...
You clearly didn't take the time to fully read and understand my post. Nothing in my post points to whether or not a 600 yard shot is feasible - I even made that specifically clear...."It isn't so much the fact of a 600 yard shot, that is for a different discussion"
 
Dads a gunsmith and routinely practices that far. I am sure there are kids capable of shots like that. Good equipment, data from shooting, a calculator, and understanding is all that it takes beyond good shooting skills.

Doesnt mean all of the people reading this can or should do that. I think some long range shooters, and perhaps this journalist, kind of make it akin to "8 mile packout" and other feats of manhood, but its sort of the opposite. It doesnt take much but some math to turn a dial. It should be about the terrain, cover, wind, etc.

I have never lost an animal with a rifle. I know people who have lost several. I have passed shots i could probably make, but why should that animal chance a suffering death? Articles like this tend to make people think "if she can, i can" instead of what people should think "do i have a near certain probability of a lethal hit and recovery."
 
seeth07 said:
Am I the only one feeling a bit disgusted by this article? It isn't so much the fact of a 600 yard shot, that is for a different discussion, but by the fact that the article highlights it being 600 yards. Why not just remove the range from the story? Shooting 600 yards takes practice and solid knowledge of the ballistics of your rifle and ammo and I'm not a fan of the article promoting the shot distance as a highlight of the event. She may be able to do it but does this make others now think they can when they shouldn't be?

There is also this from the article:
View attachment 394556

Why are you only practicing to 500 yards but then in the field taking a 600 yard shot? The ballistics are significantly different between those two ranges and its another MOA into your on target shot variance.
Click to expand...
Sorry for the fact the article "highlights" the range and that makes you butthurt, but what else bothers you, the size of the bull and that giant muley buck?

I see it totally different. There's no doubt Kaci has a father/mentor that is bringing her up into hunting. He has her practice at 500 yards, which easily prepares her for a 600 yard shot. With the proper equipment there is not an issue. Obviously she was trained to not to take a shot unless she was very steady. So far so good.

I would question the father allowing her to take such sizable animals at such a young age, though that is his/her choice. We are much less selective with the 12 year olds in my family. But that's us. Hopefully she continues hunting and has the drive even though future elk and deer she takes may not be as large as the two in the article. Nice job Kaci and dad!
 
JM77 said:
Sorry for the fact the article "highlights" the range and that makes you butthurt, but what else bothers you, the size of the bull and that giant muley buck?

I see it totally different. There's no doubt Kaci has a father/mentor that is bringing her up into hunting. He has her practice at 500 yards, which easily prepares her for a 600 yard shot. With the proper equipment there is not an issue. Obviously she was trained to not to take a shot unless she was very steady. So far so good.

I would question the father allowing her to take such sizable animals at such a young age, though that is his/her choice. We are much less selective with the 12 year olds in my family. But that's us. Hopefully she continues hunting and has the drive even though future elk and deer she takes may not be as large as the two in the article. Nice job Kaci and dad!
Click to expand...
You too are missing my point. My point has nothing to do with Kaci and their situation. My beef is with the author that choses to put in the front spotlight the distance and not express warning or caution or anything of the such to the readers about the situation. It just adds to the garbage hunting media that continues to lead to more and more unethical behavior among the hunting group.
 
Last edited:
seeth07 said:
You too are missing my point. My point has nothing to do with Kaci and their situation. My beef is with the author that choses to put in the front spotlight the distance and not express warning or caution or anything of the such to the readers about the situation. It just adds the garbage hunting media that continues to lead to more and more unethical behavior among the hunting group.
Click to expand...
Do you know how to read? Try my first sentence.
 
JM77 said:
Sorry for the fact the article "highlights" the range and that makes you butthurt, but what else bothers you, the size of the bull and that giant muley buck?
Click to expand...
Sure can. Nothing else bothers me. Just don't want the range highlighted. 600 yards is not a normal range that anybody can just pick up and do - which is what happens when someone used to shooting a shotgun in the thick woods of the East reads an article about a 12 year being able to shoot 600 yards like its nothing and he thinks, well if she can do it so can I and heads to Montana and wounds 3 elk before finally knocking one down.
 
Last edited:
You must log in or register to reply here.

Similar threads

CPAjeff
One Shot, Years in the Making
2
Replies
35
Views
2K
Lucky hunting sweater
L
WyoDoug
Spry Wyoming Doe Has Burn Marks To Prove She Outran Huge Elk Fire
Replies
0
Views
605
WyoDoug
WyoDoug
cbang65
Recovering from an awful hunting season
Replies
16
Views
870
2rocky
2rocky
O
First Elk finally
2 3
Replies
45
Views
3K
jls456
J
M
Shooting fast, is more important than shooting far.
2
Replies
20
Views
5K
BAKPAKR
BAKPAKR

Latest posts

Forum statistics

Threads
117,646
Messages
2,163,761
Members
38,308
Latest member
CS45

Share this page

Back
Top