which one?

[SJ]

We are putting together a new banner to use for link exchanges and I was interested in your input on which one you like the best.
1.

2.

 

[whitedeer]

#1 appeals to my manly instinct, such as it is.......#2 seems a little bit on the PollyAnna side......just MHO!

 

[Mojave]

The first one is more artistic and my preference in general. The second one popped out at me though and caught my attention first when I opened the page so if you are looking for attention grabbing, I'd go there.

 

[Michaelr]

1st is the best

 

[JohnSWA]

Just my opinion, but #2 is much more brighter and catchier to the eye! Just my lil ol girly opinion! LOL!

 

[the nikster]

#2 just seems easier on the eyes. Both look really nice though...

 

[noharleyyet]

#1 looks like autumn...like it.

 

[danr55]

The directional layout of the second one seems to flow more than the first.. The colors in the second one are brighter and more vibrant. If it's advertising you're looking for, number two is my choice.

 

[mtmiller]

I prefer #1.

 

[Whiskers]

I prefer #1 but #2 is the one that drew my attention first.

 

[wilecoyote76]

Heck, I say use them both. #1 in the fall, then #2 in the spring. Seems fitting. I prefer #1 though.

 

[WH's OutdoorsChick]

I like #2...It is bright and really sticks out...One is good to but it is a little bland.......

 

[SJ]

Thanks ya'll I really appreciate your input and opinions. These two are actually the remaining 2 of 5 that we started out with and we were trying to get it down to 1 but from evryone's opinions from several forums we decided to take wilecoyote76 and several other's advise and will use both depending on seasons and also backgrounds of the sites they well be displayed on. We have decided also to to change out the elephant for a Cape Buffalo on both finished banners. Thanks again ya'll.

 

[huntinfool]

The 2nd one definitely catches the eye more than the 1st one does
but personally I like the 1 st one better

 

[wyomuley]

I would go with the first one

 

[Quiet_One]

Igo with the #2 way more prettier and catchy

 

[Bandit]

I would have to say the same as wiliwcoyote, use them both, according to the weather.

 

[ELKCHSR]

I don't know which red 'x' is better...

 

[WH's OutdoorsChick]

Yeah I cant decide either