Wow, that thread grew quickly. I have to say, I've seen this statue many, many times. That stretch of Central Park West is one of my secret parking hot spots when I stay in Manhattan for work.
The actual artistry of the statue is pretty impressive and Teddy R definitely earned some respect from us. However, this statue, in this day and age, really looks tone deaf, I've always thought so. It really is a regal looking white guy on a horse, leading the way while his "lessers" walk behind him, on foot. That's what the statue feels like. If there were a statue of TR there, by himself, I don't think we'd be hearing any calls for its removal. I think removing it is probably a good move.