The following morning, we told my wifes stepdad that he should just stay around camp and focus entirely on his deer tag. His body needed a bit of a rest and there were plenty of deer in and around our camp location. We also liked the idea of having someone there just to see if any elk were there as well. The other three of us would hike not just to the rock but immediately go past it and up the next top of the ridge to already be able to look into the right valley at daybreak.
We get there with plenty of time and with it being finally nice and calm this morning we can immediately hear bugling. Lots of it! There is a young bull in the bottom of the left valley almost in the same spot as the bull from the day before as well as numerous bulls in the the right valley away from the main herd which is in the exact same spot as the day before except they are really strung out across a vast area. Closest to us, the same broken bull and 4x4 are within rifle range.
We decide to make a plan to head down a little bit further before crossing the valley and getting up on the other side. Near the top on the other side we could see a large bull had pushed 30 or so cows away from the main herd and this is the bull I thought we should target. He was about 2 miles total away but I figured we had plenty of time to make it happen since the sun hasnt even crested the mountain tops to the east yet.
While in route, that group with the bull we were targetting bedded among a small patch of dark timber which was fantastic giving is a perfect mark and plan for making our stalk.
The herd bull with his cows are just short of that clump of dark timber high and slightly right in the photo.
We get down the ridge almost a mile as planned and make our decent into the valley in no time. We are near the bottom and we hear a gun shot followed up by 3 more! We look as far left as we can down our ridge and a guy is shooting easily close to 1000 yards into the main herd! We catch the wounded bull, he has a broken rear leg and then 3 more shots ring out and the bull keeps going. He eventually beds after going about a mile. All of the elk in the valley herd up quick, all running along the opposite side of the valley but in our direction. Then we hear crashing and realize that some of the elk are on our side and we start to see elk coming our way and I get the rifle ready. In total, 13 bulls pass by us all within 200 yards but every single one is either a small white horned bull or has a main beam broken. The main herd also passed in front of us within 1000 yards or so and we were able to look over every bull in the group, probably 50 total or so and disappointment started to set in a bit as it was the same story except for that one main herd bull was a pretty darn good impressive bull. The hunter was able to get close to the bedded bull and another shot killed the bull.
We had a good hunch that the herd was going to head to the spot where my wife and I first spotted them on the first hunting day so we decided to make a break in that direction. Sure enough, by the time we got over there and about 700 yards away the herd showed up and immediately bedded in a tucked away bowl out of the wind. We were below them and basically stuck with no real ability to make a move without a massive long hike completley around and above them. We sat and ate lunch looking over all the bulls closely again and we indeed determined that only the large herd bull was really something special. The problem was that in the hour we spent watching him, he fought two different smaller broken bulls and the reality is he very well might not have those antlers intact for long. There is no doubt that with a bull to cow ratio of what appeared to be close to 1 to 1, these bulls go through some pure hell during the rut.
Herd just above us 700 yards away. *In idiot rifle range*
During that time while relaxing eating lunch and watching the main herd, we had watched the huge broken bull and the small 4x4 with him actually walk pretty close to us and bed down only 300 yards away. I told my wife that I thought I should just shoot this bull and I would be happy with the result. I told her that if I could stalk to within 200 yards of him and setup for a perfect clean shot I wad gonna do it. I attempted to make that happen but the old bruiser was too keen to be tricked. With little cover to work with and being below him in the direction he was facing, he easily picked me out in no time and got nervous. He even barked once at me before slowly trotting away and directly into the main herd. The rest of the elk gave no care to his bark. I got back together with my wife and buddy and we made the disaapointing long hike back to camp. It was still a fun day and I could have easily punched my tag numerous times but having one of the other 5 hunters for this hunt do some long range shooting and ruining our plan for our stalk still left a bitter taste in my mouth. I get it that it's public land hunting but shooting beyond 400-500 yards to me is just pure stupidity, you aren't changing my mind ever on that no matter how much you tell me you practice. To top that, after looking over about 100 bulls total or so, there is only one unbroken bull that we saw in this entire area that wasn't small (4x4 or less) or broken. The choices moving forward were shoot a small/broken bull, hunt the herd bull or change our game plan and look for a mature bull all on his own recovering from the hard rut. Back at camp my wife and I talked over these options and made the decision that the next day we would try for the herd bull but not entirely dedicate to him as we also wouldn't pass up something easy on any bull that wasn't a raghorn. Forecast for that night and the next day wasn't good calling for heavy rain and fog. Just before we went to bed, the rain started and never stopped by the time the alarm went off early in the morning again.
Are hunting selfies now a requirement in hunt stories? Wasn't sure as it appears most have them now. Plus my wife wanted one and she gets what she wants!
