Wife's Shotgun Broke (advice on a replacement)

RG_Adult_Onset_Hunter

Active member
Joined
Dec 10, 2019
Messages
94
Location
Ruch, Oregon
Ugh.

So I got my wife a Franchi Instinct last year on clearance before the Instinct line split into several different sub models. We also got it shortened to her absurdly short LOP of 12.5" and installed a Gracoil on it. She now love turkey hunting, but this gun has given her grief from word go, and I can just tell it does not point quite right for her to shoot instinctually. The last straw for the gun is that the stock seems to have had a defect and developed a sizable crack in right around the pistol grip where it joins to the receiver. I am contacting Franchi to see about repairs, but I don't know how that is going to pan out with the aftermarket mods. That said what are my options for replacement given the following criteria?

She wants:
An Over Under
Auto Safety on break, and preferably a tang selector
12 gauge as she wants to use it for turkey and waterfowl
recoil reduction would be nice if possible
a stock that actually fits her
The gun should be a tough as nails HUNTING gun, not some competition toy

Given that she has had bad experiences with this gun, she is loathe to put down more money on a Franchi Catalyst Instinct. This has left me with calling the Orvis gun shop for a custom rig...are there any obvious options I am missing? Are there other custom options we should look at?
 

Slam

Member
Joined
Aug 30, 2007
Messages
194
My first question would be why an O/U?

Second, why 12 gauge only? Both my kids grew up shooting 20's and never a problem on turkey or waterfowl, geese included.

A gas operated auto (especially in 20) will mitigate recoil, add a youth stock and you may find it fits and shoots well for her. Some come with a tang safety.
 

RG_Adult_Onset_Hunter

Active member
Joined
Dec 10, 2019
Messages
94
Location
Ruch, Oregon
My first question would be why an O/U?

Second, why 12 gauge only? Both my kids grew up shooting 20's and never a problem on turkey or waterfowl, geese included.

A gas operated auto (especially in 20) will mitigate recoil, add a youth stock and you may find it fits and shoots well for her. Some come with a tang safety.
The O/U is non negotiable to her, she likes the methodical way they operate and the safety of being able to carry the gun safely open in the field. I'd agree with you on the gas operated auto, but that action is not for her.

As to the 20 gauge, she is way more open to that. Good to know they have been field tested to take geese.
 

RG_Adult_Onset_Hunter

Active member
Joined
Dec 10, 2019
Messages
94
Location
Ruch, Oregon
Not sure if it fits all of your needs, but Syren shotguns are built for women
Funny, we have been looking at the Syrens. The Elos D2 in particular caught her eye. I remeasured her LOP as opposed to just measuring her gun, she is about 13.25", the Syrens are a bit long, but I might be able to get it cut down at the factory for something so small. If not, a 12mm recoil pad would shave off .47" so that might be about perfect (at the expense of a bit more felt recoil, but she has been shooting a lightweight 12 gauge with turkey loads without too much issue).

I'll let you know what the factory says about tweaking the gun a bit.
 

Boomerusaf

Well-known member
Joined
Jul 14, 2018
Messages
2,508
Location
The Driftless Region
It's a shotgun. Plenty of simple options as well. 20 gauges kill ducks and turkeys.

We're not talking rocket science here. If you've specified that much already. Then what's the point of asking us? Sorry, not to be rude. I think you're overthinking this one. Semis and pumps are fantastic options.
 

BrentD

Well-known member
Joined
Feb 3, 2018
Messages
3,084
Location
In the middle
If she wants and Over/Under then get an O/U and cut it down, install chokes, and make it fit.

My wife has an Ithaca/SKB side-by-side in 20 gauge. Not because 20 gauge is enough, but because it is lighter than a 12. She also doesn't hunt geese. I would try to stick with a 12 for your wife given her interests in the big dinosaurs. 20s will work, but 12s will work better. That's why they make'em. They do weigh more however.

In my opinion, the autoloader is not a great choice for a smaller person. So much of the gun is the action. Just makes it clunky and weirdly balanced with tube mag, etc. So, her choice of O/U is, fundamentally, a good one.

Auto Safety is good idea too. Sounds like she really knows what she likes and what she needs. Why not a Browning Citori in some flavor?
 

F250

Active member
Joined
Dec 9, 2011
Messages
571
Location
Vermont
Save yourself some heartburn and let her choose the gun she wants. My wife chose a Beretta 686 in 12 ga. a couple decades ago. We had the stock cut to fit her. She's killed a pile of waterfowl with that O/U. We have a detachable sling on it for those long hikes across Saskatchewan fields. She also used it turkey hunting. There are lots of good O/Us on the market. From our experience, the 686 fills all her requests.
 

RG_Adult_Onset_Hunter

Active member
Joined
Dec 10, 2019
Messages
94
Location
Ruch, Oregon
Save yourself some heartburn and let her choose the gun she wants. My wife chose a Beretta 686 in 12 ga. a couple decades ago. We had the stock cut to fit her. She's killed a pile of waterfowl with that O/U. We have a detachable sling on it for those long hikes across Saskatchewan fields. She also used it turkey hunting. There are lots of good O/Us on the market. From our experience, the 686 fills all her requests.
That's kind of my philosophy at this point. She just wanted guidance from me as far as avoiding a really poor fit. She is going to grab the Syren Elos D2 in 20 gauge. I'll let you all know if it fits the bill.
 

Europe

Well-known member
Joined
Dec 26, 2018
Messages
780
If she wants and Over/Under then get an O/U and cut it down, install chokes, and make it fit.

My wife has an Ithaca/SKB side-by-side in 20 gauge. Not because 20 gauge is enough, but because it is lighter than a 12. She also doesn't hunt geese. I would try to stick with a 12 for your wife given her interests in the big dinosaurs. 20s will work, but 12s will work better. That's why they make'em. They do weigh more however.

In my opinion, the autoloader is not a great choice for a smaller person. So much of the gun is the action. Just makes it clunky and weirdly balanced with tube mag, etc. So, her choice of O/U is, fundamentally, a good one.

Auto Safety is good idea too. Sounds like she really knows what she likes and what she needs. Why not a Browning Citori in some flavor?
A lot of good points !

Have her visit Connecticut and see if she likes their shotguns. They will make what she wants and make it to fit her. She will have a tough as nails hunting gun, not some competitive toy AND it will last her a lifetime and FIT her.
 

RG_Adult_Onset_Hunter

Active member
Joined
Dec 10, 2019
Messages
94
Location
Ruch, Oregon
A lot of good points !

Have her visit Connecticut and see if she likes their shotguns. They will make what she wants and make it to fit her. She will have a tough as nails hunting gun, not some competitive toy AND it will last her a lifetime and FIT her.
Those are some pretty pieces of steel. I'll pass that along.
 

RG_Adult_Onset_Hunter

Active member
Joined
Dec 10, 2019
Messages
94
Location
Ruch, Oregon
UPDATE:

Yesterday we put in an order for a Syren Elos D2 20 guage. They will shave off a half an inch of LOP at the factory. They also will install an auto safety. So that should check all her requirement boxes. It's 6 weeks out, but I'll pass along her thoughts on the gun in case anyone else is looking.
 

jjubran

Member
Joined
Apr 11, 2016
Messages
50
Location
Houston, TX
UPDATE:

Yesterday we put in an order for a Syren Elos D2 20 guage. They will shave off a half an inch of LOP at the factory. They also will install an auto safety. So that should check all her requirement boxes. It's 6 weeks out, but I'll pass along her thoughts on the gun in case anyone else is looking.
sounds like a solid plan. Looking forward to the update.
 

2rocky

Well-known member
Joined
Jul 23, 2010
Messages
2,115
A lot of good points !

Have her visit Connecticut and see if she likes their shotguns. They will make what she wants and make it to fit her. She will have a tough as nails hunting gun, not some competitive toy AND it will last her a lifetime and FIT her.
I took a look at that page and there is some serious coin for those shotguns. Beautiful though. Quite a few used models as well.
 

Kensley

Active member
Joined
Jul 12, 2018
Messages
174
Location
Bozemen, Montana
Not 100% sure if they make a youth stock but the Stroger overunders are freakin fantastic. My dad bought one 20 years ago and I would rabbit hunt with it all the time, easy to aim. But generally I use my 20g pump for just about anything. My rem 1100 mostly sits and looks pretty in the safe while the mossburg 500 20g pump gets all the work. I see that you had mechanical issues with your wifes so I would suggest a mossburg for pure reliability. I have beat the piss out of that thing since I was a kid and it has been a great gun. They are also cheap and plentiful.
 

2rocky

Well-known member
Joined
Jul 23, 2010
Messages
2,115
Not 100% sure if they make a youth stock but the Stroger overunders are freakin fantastic. My dad bought one 20 years ago and I would rabbit hunt with it all the time, easy to aim. But generally I use my 20g pump for just about anything. My rem 1100 mostly sits and looks pretty in the safe while the mossburg 500 20g pump gets all the work. I see that you had mechanical issues with your wifes so I would suggest a mossburg for pure reliability. I have beat the piss out of that thing since I was a kid and it has been a great gun. They are also cheap and plentiful.
Just to let you know...He went with a shotgun that has an MSRP of $2895
He's playing in a little different league than us.


UPDATE:

Yesterday we put in an order for a Syren Elos D2 20 guage. They will shave off a half an inch of LOP at the factory. They also will install an auto safety. So that should check all her requirement boxes. It's 6 weeks out, but I'll pass along her thoughts on the gun in case anyone else is looking.
 
Top