We take my truck 95% of the time. Mine is the newest truck (2017) in the group right now and I will take it wherever I need to go. Others have older trucks that are almost perfect. I carry tow straps, tire chains, jumper cables, tarps, game bags, water and lots of other things that I may or may not need. Others tell me they will not fill their truck up with all of that junk. It isn't junk it is what I need to hunt with.
Most days they want to take my truck in case we get something we won't have to return to camp for a back pack, or game bags or a who knows what. I prefer being in mine since I feel I have what I need and if the road is brushy or muddy oh well we just keep going.
I have actually been on hunts where guys would wash their truck in the middle of a hunt even though the roads are covered in mud or snow. They cannot stand to see mud on their 4 wheel drive trucks.