I know this is an old thread but I just got back from a Kentucky archery elk hunt and would like to offer some of my big takeaways. I hunted with an outfitter due to access challenges, he was great and provided some insight as to the KY elk situation.
1. Kentucky has a reputation for being the land of 400" bulls behind every tree screaming their heads off. Flush that from your mind. 10 or 15 years ago that may have been slightly true, but the reality now is that the herd is in decline. Part of this is due to too many tags, part of it is poor habitat management, and part of it is due to rampant black bear populations.
2. In regards to habitat, much of the reclaimed strip mines have been overrun by an invasive vine called kudzu. It can grow nearly a foot a day and literally eats the forest. As a result, much of the grassy meadows that the elk rely on are disappearing.
3. Bears. We saw more bear sign on this hunt than anywhere I've ever been. According to my source, KDFWR is in denial about the effect that bears have on elk, particularly in regards to calves.
This is just a brief synopsis of some of the issues going on in Kentucky that are not public knowledge. When I drew my tag, I was under the impression that it was the glory tag of a lifetime. Make no mistake, I enjoyed the experience, and made some new connections with great people, but the hunting was not anything like the web would have you believe.
@Big Fin I bring this up because I worry the KY elk herd is in danger. You've had rep from KDFWR on the podcast before I believe, I strongly encourage you to try and get a representative from KEGA (Kentucky Elk Guide Association) on the podcast, I believe you will hear a different perspective, and the data to back it up.