The Fishin’ Was Too Good

Big Fin

Administrator
Staff member
Joined
Dec 27, 2000
Messages
17,146
Location
Bozeman, MT
After being on the road almost non-stop since January, I was pretty excited to head out for a walleye fishing trip. We had planned three days of fishing, but with the wind forecast being terrible, I cut it to two days, knowing the futility of fighting Montana prairie winds.

While packing and loading the truck, boat, and trailer, it seemed the cranking battery for big outboard finally laid down after way too many years. Run around Bozeman to find one that would work. A three-hour delay. No biggie. Instead of getting to the motel at 10pm, it would be 1am, making a 4am wake up seem like a short night.

The alarm went off. I hit snooze, noticing Mrs. Fin was not even phased by the alarm noises. Next time I woke, it was 7am. Crap, missed the best fishing hours. Oh well, we came to relax, even if it came at the cost of prime fishing.

By the time we got loaded, gobbled down breakfast and coffee, drove to the ramp and launched the boat, we were finally motoring out of the bay by 10:00 am. Before turning the corner, I noticed the a familiar boat. I pulled up beside one of our friends, already on his way in, having had a good morning bite that had died down. He gave the report, bait used, depths, speed, and other essentials he and I share with each other. Always a great shortcut when a trusted friend, who is one of the best fisherman, gives you fresh intel.

Within minutes after dropping lines at the first point, we had bites. An hour in and we had nine walleyes. Then a about an hour lull, with some pike and perch annoying me and stealing spinners and baits.

Then, for reasons I don't understand, it was fast and furious. Those fish we had been seeing on the electronics decided it was lunch time. At one time, all four rods had fish. Tough to net that many walleyes in one net at one time. It was big laughs, and a much-needed break.

Mrs. Fin outfished me in a big way. Since I am the “tender,” baiting lines, netting fish, navigating electronics, retying spinners devoured by pike, I feel there is adequate reason for my second-rate fish boarding.

When we had plowed through the first three dozen night crawlers, I switched over to Gulp worms while she fished the last remnants of crawlers. I caught zero. I estimate she boated 8-10 more. Truly one of the best days we’ve had in some time.

Watching the few other boats and talking to some people, I think we just lucked out and found hungry fish. Sometimes it works that way. I’ll take it. It makes up for the days when I hadn’t lucked into a pod of hungry fish and others fishing nearby had a day like we had.

IMG_5448.jpg

And here is why the fishing was "too good." For those of you who have a Lund Pro-V with the very wide rear livewell, you’ll relate to this part of the story.

I bleed my fish about ten minutes before I fillet them. They bleed to death, and with walleyes, their meat becomes almost transparent if done properly. Just a quick poke between the pelvic fins, up toward the gills, and the heart gets a bad leak. They are done in a minute. Once bled, I dump them in starboard side of my livewell. There is a removable divider between the starboard/port side of this 48” livewell that makes it handy for sorting fish when you are upgrading on the good days.

When it's "guttin & gillin' time" I always keep two fish “unbled” and alive to make sure of my count. Maybe math isn’t my best subject, but when it’s fast and furious, it’s easy to end up with a livewell that holds one more or one less than the daily limit. The two “unbled” fish stay alive until I’ve counted the dead bled ones.

With a daily limit of five each, Mrs. Fin and I are good for ten fish each day, twenty in possession. So, I start counting the floaters who have been bled and placed on the starboard side of the livewell. One, Two, Three,…….Six, Seven, Eight. Great, eight dead and bled. Grab the two live ones and bleed them.

I fillet all the fish, rinse them well, and get them on ice. I set the livewell pump to “empty.” Pull the livewell plug and watch it drain, plucking out whatever these walleyes puked up in the livewell. As the water level slowly drops, I see a white belly over in the dark corner of the livewell. What? In 50 years of fishing, I’ve never messed this up before.

Now, I’ve got eleven “bled” fish, ten of which are in a cooler, one of which is floating in the livewell. I tell Mrs. Fin of my mistake. She’s in disbelief. I tell her that I’m not wasting a fish. I’m going to fillet that fish. If I see a warden, I’ll fess up to my stupidity and I’ll pay the fine. If I don’t see a warden, our limit tomorrow is nine and we’ll be at the possession limit of twenty.

We head to shore around 3pm. I load the boat and Mrs. Fin drives the trailered boat, with me in it, up the ramp to park. I start securing the boat to the trailer and I see a warden drive up. I tell Mrs. Fin I’ll take the hit on this one. As he walks towards our truck, I meet him and explain that he’ll need to go get his ticket book.

I tell the warden I ended up with one fish over my limit and that I’m willing to take a citation rather than wasting meat due to my stupid mistake. When I tell him what happened, he gives a comforting smile, tells me it happens more than I probably expect, and asks for my information. He comes back and hands me the ticket that was due; $135.

A very nice guy. He has checked us out on the water before. We visit for a while. Mrs. Fin starts to brag about how she outfished me by a mile. The warden jokes that he made a mistake, and he should write the ticket in her name.

So, I sit here at the hotel, embarrassed as hell. Wondering how an accountant can’t count to ten accurately. I now have one speeding ticket in my life and one fishing citation. Hopefully one of each is enough.

Call my buddy who we met on the water and tell him thanks for the intel and what a great bite it was for a few hours. He has a boat almost identical to mine, with the same livewell setup. I tell him what happened. He laughs and tells me a story of how a fish got caught over in the corner of his livewell and was left rotting in there for a week.

Mrs. Fin and I are working on our protocols to make sure we never end up with eleven fish in the livewell, let alone eleven fish “bled and dead.” We might luck out and have a day like today once a season, probably more like once every other season. And when we do, the next day is usually a 2-4 fish day. If that pattern holds course, I won’t have to worry about my fish counting problems getting more in trouble.

Uggh. What a stupid way to ruin a great day of fishing.

Better get showered and sleeping. Not missing the daylight bite tomorrow.
 
Great report.
Wish I was back there plucking those pike harassing your worms.😁
You would have loved it. Had two walleyes near the boat that got devoured by huge pike. Fought them for a bit, only to have them spit out the walleye right when they got near the boat. Both were in that 15# range and it wouldn't surprise me if it was the same pike that did it on two different fish.

I hate those things when I'm fishing walleyes. Marcus says I should keep them and bring them to him. Mrs. Fin is not allowing such slime balls in her boat.
 
You would have loved it. Had two walleyes near the boat that got devoured by huge pike. Fought them for a bit, only to have them spit out the walleye right when they got near the boat. Both were in that 15# range and it wouldn't surprise me if it was the same pike that did it on two different fish.

I hate those things when I'm fishing walleyes. Marcus says I should keep them and bring them to him. Mrs. Fin is not allowing such slime balls in her boat.
I would take that 15 pounder in a second....
Slimy, yes,...way slimy.
Struggled getting a grip on this one.🤣Screenshot_20250517_155344_Gallery.jpg
 
You would have loved it. Had two walleyes near the boat that got devoured by huge pike. Fought them for a bit, only to have them spit out the walleye right when they got near the boat. Both were in that 15# range and it wouldn't surprise me if it was the same pike that did it on two different fish.

I hate those things when I'm fishing walleyes. Marcus says I should keep them and bring them to him. Mrs. Fin is not allowing such slime balls in her boat.
It's not hard to get rid of the bones. After that, they're pretty good eating!
 
So got any walleye recipes?
I tried shore lunch and it didn't turn out too well
 
Easy to do and would almost rather have that then what happened to a friend who had missed a fish and didn't find it for a week in the heat of the summer in his well.

Have had a 2000 lund 2025 pro v forever. Years ago when our kids were young they use to refer to the rear well as the swimming pool. Can play hide and seek in that back corner of the swimming pool.

Great story! Stuff happens. Bet it won't happen again.

There was a ton of eyes in the pool in the pic but most of them were hiding in the back corner.

20250605_224158.jpg
 
After being on the road almost non-stop since January, I was pretty excited to head out for a walleye fishing trip. We had planned three days of fishing, but with the wind forecast being terrible, I cut it to two days, knowing the futility of fighting Montana prairie winds.

While packing and loading the truck, boat, and trailer, it seemed the cranking battery for big outboard finally laid down after way too many years. Run around Bozeman to find one that would work. A three-hour delay. No biggie. Instead of getting to the motel at 10pm, it would be 1am, making a 4am wake up seem like a short night.

The alarm went off. I hit snooze, noticing Mrs. Fin was not even phased by the alarm noises. Next time I woke, it was 7am. Crap, missed the best fishing hours. Oh well, we came to relax, even if it came at the cost of prime fishing.

By the time we got loaded, gobbled down breakfast and coffee, drove to the ramp and launched the boat, we were finally motoring out of the bay by 10:00 am. Before turning the corner, I noticed the a familiar boat. I pulled up beside one of our friends, already on his way in, having had a good morning bite that had died down. He gave the report, bait used, depths, speed, and other essentials he and I share with each other. Always a great shortcut when a trusted friend, who is one of the best fisherman, gives you fresh intel.

Within minutes after dropping lines at the first point, we had bites. An hour in and we had nine walleyes. Then a about an hour lull, with some pike and perch annoying me and stealing spinners and baits.

Then, for reasons I don't understand, it was fast and furious. Those fish we had been seeing on the electronics decided it was lunch time. At one time, all four rods had fish. Tough to net that many walleyes in one net at one time. It was big laughs, and a much-needed break.

Mrs. Fin outfished me in a big way. Since I am the “tender,” baiting lines, netting fish, navigating electronics, retying spinners devoured by pike, I feel there is adequate reason for my second-rate fish boarding.

When we had plowed through the first three dozen night crawlers, I switched over to Gulp worms while she fished the last remnants of crawlers. I caught zero. I estimate she boated 8-10 more. Truly one of the best days we’ve had in some time.

Watching the few other boats and talking to some people, I think we just lucked out and found hungry fish. Sometimes it works that way. I’ll take it. It makes up for the days when I hadn’t lucked into a pod of hungry fish and others fishing nearby had a day like we had.

View attachment 374038

And here is why the fishing was "too good." For those of you who have a Lund Pro-V with the very wide rear livewell, you’ll relate to this part of the story.

I bleed my fish about ten minutes before I fillet them. They bleed to death, and with walleyes, their meat becomes almost transparent if done properly. Just a quick poke between the pelvic fins, up toward the gills, and the heart gets a bad leak. They are done in a minute. Once bled, I dump them in starboard side of my livewell. There is a removable divider between the starboard/port side of this 48” livewell that makes it handy for sorting fish when you are upgrading on the good days.

When it's "guttin & gillin' time" I always keep two fish “unbled” and alive to make sure of my count. Maybe math isn’t my best subject, but when it’s fast and furious, it’s easy to end up with a livewell that holds one more or one less than the daily limit. The two “unbled” fish stay alive until I’ve counted the dead bled ones.

With a daily limit of five each, Mrs. Fin and I are good for ten fish each day, twenty in possession. So, I start counting the floaters who have been bled and placed on the starboard side of the livewell. One, Two, Three,…….Six, Seven, Eight. Great, eight dead and bled. Grab the two live ones and bleed them.

I fillet all the fish, rinse them well, and get them on ice. I set the livewell pump to “empty.” Pull the livewell plug and watch it drain, plucking out whatever these walleyes puked up in the livewell. As the water level slowly drops, I see a white belly over in the dark corner of the livewell. What? In 50 years of fishing, I’ve never messed this up before.

Now, I’ve got eleven “bled” fish, ten of which are in a cooler, one of which is floating in the livewell. I tell Mrs. Fin of my mistake. She’s in disbelief. I tell her that I’m not wasting a fish. I’m going to fillet that fish. If I see a warden, I’ll fess up to my stupidity and I’ll pay the fine. If I don’t see a warden, our limit tomorrow is nine and we’ll be at the possession limit of twenty.

We head to shore around 3pm. I load the boat and Mrs. Fin drives the trailered boat, with me in it, up the ramp to park. I start securing the boat to the trailer and I see a warden drive up. I tell Mrs. Fin I’ll take the hit on this one. As he walks towards our truck, I meet him and explain that he’ll need to go get his ticket book.

I tell the warden I ended up with one fish over my limit and that I’m willing to take a citation rather than wasting meat due to my stupid mistake. When I tell him what happened, he gives a comforting smile, tells me it happens more than I probably expect, and asks for my information. He comes back and hands me the ticket that was due; $135.

A very nice guy. He has checked us out on the water before. We visit for a while. Mrs. Fin starts to brag about how she outfished me by a mile. The warden jokes that he made a mistake, and he should write the ticket in her name.

So, I sit here at the hotel, embarrassed as hell. Wondering how an accountant can’t count to ten accurately. I now have one speeding ticket in my life and one fishing citation. Hopefully one of each is enough.

Call my buddy who we met on the water and tell him thanks for the intel and what a great bite it was for a few hours. He has a boat almost identical to mine, with the same livewell setup. I tell him what happened. He laughs and tells me a story of how a fish got caught over in the corner of his livewell and was left rotting in there for a week.

Mrs. Fin and I are working on our protocols to make sure we never end up with eleven fish in the livewell, let alone eleven fish “bled and dead.” We might luck out and have a day like today once a season, probably more like once every other season. And when we do, the next day is usually a 2-4 fish day. If that pattern holds course, I won’t have to worry about my fish counting problems getting more in trouble.

Uggh. What a stupid way to ruin a great day of fishing.

Better get showered and sleeping. Not missing the daylight bite tomorrow.
I listened to a podcast with an interview with a semi-famous Western warden.
His words: If you hunt and fish long enough, you WILL break a game law… mostly by accident.

I am a little jealous of your wallye success Randy. 🥴😁
 
Last edited:
You would have loved it. Had two walleyes near the boat that got devoured by huge pike. Fought them for a bit, only to have them spit out the walleye right when they got near the boat. Both were in that 15# range and it wouldn't surprise me if it was the same pike that did it on two different fish.

I hate those things when I'm fishing walleyes. Marcus says I should keep them and bring them to him. Mrs. Fin is not allowing such slime balls in her boat.
Well done on the walleyes Mrs. Fin!

I absolutely love catching and eating pike! I also like cold clam chowder directly out of the can and liver and onions at the Trappers Kettle Restaurant in Belfield, if you remember those delicacies on our hunts?

I am not sure we should ever fish together. There might be some “discussions” about the throwing back of any slimy, beautiful pike.
 
It's a game of chance when the fish start biting really well and you realize you haven't been keeping count! (Or worse yet, you're keeping count and it's wrong!)

I keep a clicker handy to punch it every time I throw a fish in. It takes a bit to make it a habit, but once you do, it becomes second nature!

Enjoy those delicious fish! I just kept a limit on Wednesday night. I love eating fish.

So got any walleye recipes?
I tried shore lunch and it didn't turn out too well
You didn't like shore lunch?! That's one of my go to's!

Did you use it as a batter or a breading? Shorelunch original breaded lightly and fried at 350-375 degrees for a few mins. 😋
 
So got any walleye recipes?
I tried shore lunch and it didn't turn out too well
1/3 Shore Lunch original, 1/3 Chef Roberts breading, and 1/3 crushed (very fine) saltine cracker crumbs. Mix them together in a ziplock. Take the nice clean fillets (cut into bite size pieces and sliced thin if you have a thick fillet) and put them in the ziplock with the breading and shake it up until they are completely covered in a light coating. Don’t dip in egg or beer or any nonsense like that.

Get a cast iron kettle filled with oil. I like corn or canola, but peanut and vegetable oil work just fine, too. Heat the oil to 375. Try not to let the oil cool down to below 325ish and definitely don’t let the oil get above 400. USE A THERMOMETER. Fry the fillets until golden brown. Salt and pepper to taste. Report back. You won’t be disappointed
 

Forum statistics

Threads
117,589
Messages
2,161,581
Members
38,279
Latest member
Tom_G
Back
Top