Steps to Plan a First Time Elk Hunt - Our Goals and Questions

bklotthor

Well-known member
Joined
Dec 15, 2018
Messages
131
Location
Nebraska
Hello,

I recently started searching and reading this forum to learn about how to plan an elk hunt. A group of 3 of us have been talking about elk hunting while growing up and hunting in south central Nebraska and finally we are going to give it a try this year. We are all between the age of 27-29. So far most of my focus when searching for articles, forum posts, other hunter's hunt recaps, etc. has centered around Wyoming and Colorado. Currently we all have 2 preference points in Wyoming and zero in Colorado. Because of our preference point numbers, and the fact that we are going on our first hunt, we are thinking that Colorado makes the most sense. We are open to suggestions on this however.

Below are some bullet points of the goals/thoughts/ideas/plans/and questions that I have came up with so far. I would appreciate any feedback on the items below. Trying to decide where to go can get overwhelming for someone who has never been out there, so these are some key points I've wrote up to try and help give us some general direction. I feel like once we have determined what season and what general region to focus on the detailed research and planning will start to become less overwhelming.

1. Our goals for the hunt are: To see elk, learn how to scout and hunt elk for the given time of year we choose, and have decent chances of harvesting elk if we do our homework and hunt hard. We plan to go on multiple elk hunts in the future, so we are looking for a good entry hunt we can use as a learning experience while having fun and potentially filling tags. We plan to devote 9-10 days to the hunt from the time we leave home to the time we return home, and will likely setup a base camp to give us flexibility in where we go within a given unit as well as get accustomed to camping for a week long hunt.

2. Weapon selection and reasoning: Rifle, mainly because our thinking is that the chances of harvesting an elk are better, plus we like to glass and spot and stalk hunt.

3. We are open to hunting anywhere, since we only have two points in WY we figured it makes more sense to save those and hunt either an OTC 2nd/3rd rifle season bull tag in CO or an either sex 1st rifle limited entry unit in CO that takes zero points to draw. My questions are:

a. Are we way off base in thinking that CO rifle tags give us the best chance to meet our goals?

b. Most of the 1st rifle zero point draw units appear to also have OTC bull tags for 2nd/3rd rifle. Given that the 1st Rifle tag could be
either sex, does it make sense to apply for one of these and use the OTC tag as a backup?

c. For a first time CO rifle elk hunter, does one season have any advantage over the others? Is there less pressure in one? Are elk
easier to find in one vs the others?

d. Are there any negative reasons that some CO 1st rifle limited entry units require zero points? (i.e. difficult access, low elk numbers, too many roads, etc.)

e. Would a Wyoming cow/calf tag be more beneficial and enjoyable for us? I've read about the larger hunter numbers in CO, however I have no idea if that means that you see hunters everywhere within an easy to draw or OTC unit all week long or if the majority of hunters are more casual and stay close to their vehicles. I'm not overly concerned with high hunter numbers, unless the pressure is so high that you could go days without seeing elk on public land.

Thanks for any advice, answers, or recommendations you are willing to share.
 
If you are set on rifle, you could all probably learn alot about elk hunting quickly, avoid some frustration, and have a good chance of all being successful if you put in for cow tags in a good unit where you might otherwise not be able to draw a bull tag. You will then be likely to see more elk, more quickly. Then you can apply that knowledge on your next hunt, even if it is somewhere else where you can draw for a bull tag. Otherwise, I would strongly recommend an OTC archery hunt in one of the units that has a good herd of elk summering on National Forest land. You will be almost certain to see elk and have a great shot at a cow, and still a chance at a bull. And more predictable weather. Spot and stalk, in crowded OTC units during the later rifle seasons is going to be hit or miss unless you do your research well, as the elk are not always as visible as you might see on TV, unless you luck out with a good spot or are tipped off to where to go. They are also more likely to have moved to private or to less accessible portions of the unit (which you would not be familiar with). Thus, it's more likely you will see a lot more orange than elk. I encourage you in your efforts. I wish I could go back and relive my first couple elk hunts.
 
Back
Top