Social security by the numbers

The math is math. I don't know what you mean by "social" fix. The solution is embedded in the law - when the excess funds run out, it is a taxes collected = pay out system, which means checks will get cut by 20-25%. The problem has been ignored because people hate taxes but love cashing checks. Someone told me another stat the other day- more people enter retirement every day than are born, so it isn't going away.
Should have worded it better, social acceptance of the fix.
 
While it would only be a band aid...the money spent on the Iran war could have covered a good number of SS checks.

We have, for nearly all of my adult life, willfully chose to have larger governmental spending, than we are willing to pay for with tax revenues.

imo, the GOP showed their cards with project 2025. The long and short of it, is they would prefer to dismantle as much government as possible, to cut the marginal tax rates on income. The big beautiful bill is another clue, showing their value system. Removing government spending on health care, as a pay for reducing taxes.

There was a pressing reason that caused the creation of Social Security. Between 1/2 to 2/3 of seniors lived in poverty. That left many, either to live with an adult child or in a poorhouse. Very few people had any sort of pension. If Social Security goes away, the poverty amongst seniors will again be very common. Some number of people are okay with that, and others aren't.
 
Last edited:
While it would only be a band aid...the money spent on the Iran war could have covered a good number of SS checks.

We have, for nearly all of my adult life, willfully choose to have larger governmental spending, than we are willing to pay for with tax revenues.

imo, the GOP showed their cards with project 2025. The long and short of it, is they would prefer to dismantle as much government as possible, to cut the marginal tax rates on income. The big beautiful bill is another clue, showing their value system. Removing government spending on health care, as a pay for reducing taxes.

There was a pressing reason that caused the creation of Social Security. Between 1/2 to 2/3 of seniors lived in poverty. That left many, either to live with an adult child or in a poorhouse. Very few people had any sort of pension. If Social Security goes away, the poverty amongst seniors will again be very common. Some number of people are okay with that, and others aren't.

It's never in history been a successful tactic to cut taxes and wage war. We've been doing just that for the majority of my life.
 
It can be repaired for decades with a number of actions. The key will be whether the pain is spread broadly...although it pretty much has to be to work.

Long term we need things that are exactly the opposite of where the country has been run under Trump....and even before him.

MORE immigrants. More things that encourage births. Lower day care, health care costs, paid time off after births....simple fact is we need a lot more workers to pay in. Fewer babies...future workers...are being born than ever, and we are headed the wrong way at the same time that more people than ever are drawing.
The last thing we need is more people. Continuing the Ponzi scheme is not the answer.
 
While it would only be a band aid...the money spent on the Iran war could have covered a good number of SS checks.

We have, for nearly all of my adult life, willfully chose to have larger governmental spending, than we are willing to pay for with tax revenues.

imo, the GOP showed their cards with project 2025. The long and short of it, is they would prefer to dismantle as much government as possible, to cut the marginal tax rates on income. The big beautiful bill is another clue, showing their value system. Removing government spending on health care, as a pay for reducing taxes.

There was a pressing reason that caused the creation of Social Security. Between 1/2 to 2/3 of seniors lived in poverty. That left many, either to live with an adult child or in a poorhouse. Very few people had any sort of pension. If Social Security goes away, the poverty amongst seniors will again be very common. Some number of people are okay with that, and others aren't.
We all pay for it whether we are ok with it or not.

Was a time when republicans could be counted on to balance a checkbook. For some time they have been pushing to take less and less money in while not simultaneously cutting enough spending to balance out the lower incoming funds. In truth you simply can't cut enough spending to balance out tax cuts unless you cut the big three...SS, medicare/medicaid, and the defense budget.

What gets me is how many people still buy their lines.
 
So how would you fix social security when its main problem is fewer people paying in?
Refactor the actuarials with that assumption factored in. At least that’s the “math problem” solve. Makes the pain worse, but pretending we can breed our way out of this is ludicrous. Not to mention all of the other issues that causes.

Does anyone think this is sustainable?

1795143283175.png

Inferno by Dan Brown is an interesting read.
 
Some changes that are needed, but no wont solve the problem

- raise the min age you can claim. 62 right now and current use is to take it, the math works out that by taking less at 62, your breakeven for waiting til 67 is in your 80s. With more retirees being younger, plus longer life spans, this one is a double whammy

-raise the ss limit, yes on both end.

- any actual money generated from tarrifs, goes 100% to ss

- cut all budgets by 1%, funnel that cut to ss
 
Refactor the actuarials with that assumption factored in. At least that’s the “math problem” solve. Makes the pain worse, but pretending we can breed our way out of this is ludicrous. Not to mention all of the other issues that causes.

Does anyone think this is sustainable?

View attachment 422777

Inferno by Dan Brown is an interesting read.
MIssed the point. Its not total population growth. Although in the US that growth rate is way down too. . Its #'s of workers paying social security taxes and not drawing from SS.
IB_26-5_Figure-1.jpg
 
Some changes that are needed, but no wont solve the problem

- raise the min age you can claim. 62 right now and current use is to take it, the math works out that by taking less at 62, your breakeven for waiting til 67 is in your 80s. With more retirees being younger, plus longer life spans, this one is a double whammy

-raise the ss limit, yes on both end.

- any actual money generated from tarrifs, goes 100% to ss

- cut all budgets by 1%, funnel that cut to ss
I'd be interested in seeing the number comparison if those who take it at 62 have to wait a year longer...but then they take more than they would if they started at 62.

Cutting budgets? Where and what? Look at DOGEs cuts. How did that work out? Why has the national debt grown faster since those cuts than before?

Just as many don't understand how the decades of tax cuts have hurt and grown the national debt, many just don't understand the sheer size of the non-discretionary US obligations. A 1% spending cut is not going to add much help.
 
MIssed the point. Its not total population growth. Although in the US that growth rate is way down too. . Its #'s of workers paying social security taxes and not drawing from SS.
IB_26-5_Figure-1.jpg
I get it. But again, we’re not going to breed our way out of this. That’s as classic of a Ponzi scheme theory as there is. At some point, the pyramid crashes because the constantly accelerating growth required to sustain it is impossible to achieve. We’re pretty close to being there.
 
I get it. But again, we’re not going to breed our way out of this. That’s as classic of a Ponzi scheme theory as there is. At some point, the pyramid crashes because the constantly accelerating growth required to sustain it is impossible to achieve. We’re pretty close to being there.
I believe he is saying import our way out of it.
 
I get it. But again, we’re not going to breed our way out of this. That’s as classic of a Ponzi scheme theory as there is. At some point, the pyramid crashes because the constantly accelerating growth required to sustain it is impossible to achieve. We’re pretty close to being there.
I agree it would be hard to produce enough babies which is why we need both more focus on encouraging more and encouraging more immigration.

The issue is the large number of boomers. They will not live forever.

All this and no mention of a directly analagous issue...taxes.

Any guesses where taxes go when fewer people are paying them?
 
I agree it would be hard to produce enough babies which is why we need both more focus on encouraging more and encouraging more immigration.

The issue is the large number of boomers. They will not live forever.

All this and no mention of a directly analagous issue...taxes.

Any guesses where taxes go when fewer people are paying them?
Any guesses how much tax revenue you are going to get out of the Grand Theft Auto 6 basement dwellers?
 
I think that solving our SS problem by encouraging immigration is a non starter, politically.

I doubt whether if it would really work if we tried it, after the aggressive deportations of the last two years. It would be a tough decision to trust a foreign country to sustain a policy, after you've shown the reality of deportations.

I think it's better to find a solution of tax increases, and benefit reductions, to make the program solvent, given the reality of our population demographics.

I think immigration should be a separate issue. It should be obvious that there is a resistance to a large flow of immigrants.
 

Forum statistics

Threads
120,532
Messages
2,262,837
Members
39,138
Latest member
BigScheib
Back
Top