Big thank you to FWP for getting me these numbers. They said they had to do a little research and that's why it took them so long to reply. Still took them less than a 1.5 working days to reply so that's pretty good I think.
Looks like I was pretty close.
Last year on the old system was 2010.
2010
Big Game Combo - 19,323 people applied for 11,705 licenses = 60.6%
Deer Combination - 11,686 people applied for 3,928 licenses = 33.6%
2011 - Outfitter licenses moved into general pool so more licenses available and increased cost so less folks applied.
Big Game Combo - 16,065 people applied for 17,500 licenses = 100.0%
They said they had 1,059 surplus tags that sold within 3 days of going on sale. That doesn't add up to the 17,500, I think there are some elk only tags that mess the numbers up.
Deer Combination - 7,803 people applied for 6,589 licenses = 84.4%
I thought there were only supposed to be 4,600 Deer combination licenses so I sent an email asking for clarification on that. I think that includes landowner licenses or something.
Those numbers show a drop in applications of 3,258 for the Deer/Elk combo license and 3,883 for the Deer combo license and that is with the outfitter tags going in the general draw so really the average joe dropped off even more than that.
End result is that there are pretty good odds on drawing a tag anyway.