MTNTOUGH - Use promo code RANDY for 30 days free

Making a great meal from carp

Gut Shot

Well-known member
Joined
Mar 19, 2015
Messages
688
Location
Surrounded by the Amish Mafia
In this thread I'll tell you the secret of turning a trash fish into a great meal.

Step one is to catch a common carp. It isn't difficult in waters where they live. There are all kinds of baits that work (I prefer plain old night crawlers) spearing and archery are a lot of fun too.

Here is a 12.5lb fish but any size will work. Pay no attention to the stove sitting out by the barn, it was headed to the dump. I mean, I might be white trash but I ain't that bad.

20210605-081408.jpg


You'll notice that she is hanging from a meat hook in the gills. You can cut the gills like this or cut the end of the tail and break the spine to bleed them. Collect the blood in a ziplock or bowl.

Next step is to fillet the fish.


20210605-082140.jpg


Don't skin it. Now that it is filleted cut it into chunks. I prefer cubes about 1" in size.

Guys will tell you you have to soak it in buttermilk overnight or put it in the smoker for a few hours, that's way too much work to make a crap fish taste good. Throw all the chunks into the bag with the blood and head back down to the river.

We generally run trot lines with the bait but it will work pole fishing too. Carp works well because it is oily and their skin is very tough. That means it won't be easy to pull off once you have a hook through it.

Catch a bunch of these.

20210605-080111-0.jpg


The little 1.5-2lb channels are perfect for cooking whole. The bigger ones can be filleted or steak cut.

Beer battered catfish is awesome.

20210605-170400.jpg


So there you have it, turning a nasty, greasy trash fish into a wonderful, delicious meal.

Oh, catfish aren't the only thing you'll catch with good cut-bait. We pulled in drum, turtles, dogfish, gar and this guy.

IMG_2230.jpg


Wife and son had never seen a northern before. I was wrestling a turtle on another line while they are trying to net this one. Wife, amidst splashing and cursing, says "It's a big gar!" I looked over my shoulder and chuckled, nope you got a nice pike.
 
During four summers through high school, I worked in Zion National Park as a sous chef. One summer we had a chef from Lousiana, a really good teacher who happened to be African American. I brought back a stringer of trout from the Virgin river. He asked me if there were other types of fish and I told him the river had loads of carp and suckers besides the planted trout but I just chucked them back. He said, "no boy, thems Lousiana cutthroats (carp) and vacuum mouth bass (suckers). Bring em back and I'll show you what a real fish fry is". I did. He cooked a batch of Louisiana cutthroats. They were terrible.
 
Caribou Gear

Latest posts

Forum statistics

Threads
111,061
Messages
1,945,448
Members
35,001
Latest member
samcarp
Back
Top