Big Hank gets a get out of jail free.

44hunter45

Well-known member
Joined
Aug 14, 2019
Messages
7,569
Location
Snorth Idaho
I'm not sure if I have regrets over this or not. Still telling myself I don't. Our hunting motivations change as we age, I guess. Even 5 years ago this would have meant a dead deer.
I've killed bucks off the porch before, but it always feels more like harvesting than hunting.

Some of you know I have been getting my parents settled into elder care. No details, but this leaves you feeling like the worst son on the earth.
This has limited my hunting time since October.

Add to that the failure of more than half of the appliances in the house in the last couple of months.

Our oven failed and that necessitated converting from LP to electric. Cabinet mods, running a 40 amp 240 Vac circuit from the kitchen to the service panel. Then repairing the drywall, taping and painting. Since I had the drywall ripped off, MRS asked for some 120Vac outlets to be moved.

TLDR - The new oven arrived Tuesday afternoon and I "helped" the installer. One project done, three more to go. I'm F'ing exhausted. We were without an oven for 9 weeks. Me working first to repair the old oven, then prepping for the new one. I simply cannot get parts for a 40 year old gas oven. Always wanted a double oven for the Holidays, so time to upgrade.

In the middle of that, the LG washer threw a water valve. I was able to get the part for that and get it fixed.

Septic rooted in and backed up in the basement. Had to get that pumped. Then dry and shampoo the carpets. :sick:

Just three for Thanksgiving and I didn't feel like doing a turkey. Safeway had huge T-Bones 50% off. Heck Yeah! I bought 5. Lo and behold my oldest says he wants to come pick up Miss T and have her over for the extended weekend. Good thing I bought 5 T-Bones. They will stay the night and go back to Oregon Friday morning.

Thanksgiving goes well. We stay up too late catching up.

Friday morning I called my dad. Everyone else is sleeping in. My dad is super depressed and has given up on life. He is asking me about my hunting season and saying he wishes he could still hunt with me. I'm getting depressed too. While I'm talking to my dad I look out the window and Big Hank is cruising for late rut does 100 yards from the house. Definitely wider than his ears and tall. I tell my dad I'm watching this great buck and I should go shoot it. I'm still in my bathrobe.

I hang up with Pop and go grab the .264 out of the safe. I'm in crocs and bathrobe in front of the house. Pretty cold up my knickers. I take a rest off the back of my youngest's Honda Pilot. Chip shot. I can't bring myself to pull the trigger.

The buck moves forward about 20 yards and I move for a better angle, keeping a bull pine between us for cover. I rest on a fence post and I have him at 75 yards broadside. I control my breathing and... Let him walk away into the brush.

I feel pretty old as I walk back into the house and call my dad back. I tell him I gave the buck a pass. He says he probably would too. Maybe there is Karma credit there for when I draw that next moose tag.
 
Last edited:
You are not getting old. Good call. I have made the same decision before.

You are just making a deposit down on that "karma credit" you are talking about. Tells me you might have a heck of a draw year next year like @Mule Kick did. Although by the looks of your pics and his, you and I are definitely due for it!
 
Not virtue signalling.

Sitting here now watching three does out there. Not shooting does this year on account of EHD. If Big Hank is dumb enough to come out now I will give him the belt. Circumstances have changed, rules of engagement have changed.

Rifle season open on WT tag until 4:29PM tonight according to my legal twilight app.
 
Man, you’ve had some shit (literally) to deal with! When it rains, it pours.

I have been dealing with the same situation with my mother in law this year. She’s home now, but it caused a lot of tension with other family members.

As a result I haven’t been able to hunt but 2 or 3 times this fall. Since the snow storm deer have been feeding up in our yard where the snow blew off and grass is still exposed. Just this afternoon like an hour ago I was on the phone finishing up some issues from work while I was watching out the window and I seen a good buck walk across the road and into my yard. I ran downstairs to get my bow only to remember my release was outside in my truck.

We have a running joke in our group “not the home herd” meaning if it’s near the house it better be dam big. There’s even a mount in my basement of a basket rack that says “Not the home herd”

I hope you cash in your overdue good juju during the upcoming draws!
 
Man, you’ve had some shit (literally) to deal with! When it rains, it pours.

I have been dealing with the same situation with my mother in law this year. She’s home now, but it caused a lot of tension with other family members.

As a result I haven’t been able to hunt but 2 or 3 times this fall. Since the snow storm deer have been feeding up in our yard where the snow blew off and grass is still exposed. Just this afternoon like an hour ago I was on the phone finishing up some issues from work while I was watching out the window and I seen a good buck walk across the road and into my yard. I ran downstairs to get my bow only to remember my release was outside in my truck.

We have a running joke in our group “not the home herd” meaning if it’s near the house it better be dam big. There’s even a mount in my basement of a basket rack that says “Not the home herd”

I hope you cash in your overdue good juju during the upcoming draws!
MRS has the same rule but I can throw the exception card.
 
Enjoying this post, and can sympathize. I feel blessed to have a bit over 30 acres bordered by large ranches all around me. Every season I see a few really nice bucks come through our yard but just can't bring myself to pull the trigger...lol Then I head out on backpack hunts on public ground where I seldom see anything remotely as nice haha.

And I think it does have a bit to do with where you are at in your hunting career. I don’t consider myself old at 47 years but I can assure you that 20 years ago I would have taken a few of the deer that have walked through the yard.

Nowadays I just enjoy seeing them and doing their thing. If I'm being honest it's been over a decade since I filled a deer tag.
 
Yeah, I think you did the right thing.

A big buck walking through your yard during a difficult week, and your choice not to shoot it, can be seen as a sign of peace, restraint, transition, and reassurance; an invitation to trust your strength and stay grounded as you navigate a stressful time.

I think this would be something worth writing about to share with family later when hard times come..
 
I'm not sure if I have regrets over this or not. Still telling myself I don't. Our hunting motivations change as we age, I guess. Even 5 years ago this would have meant a dead deer.
I've killed bucks off the porch before, but it always feels more like harvesting than hunting.

Some of you know I have been getting my parents settled into elder care. No details, but this leaves you feeling like the worst son on the earth.
This has limited my hunting time since October.

Add to that the failure of more than half of the appliances in the house in the last couple of months.

Our oven failed and that necessitated converting from LP to electric. Cabinet mods, running a 40 amp 240 Vac circuit from the kitchen to the service panel. Then repairing the drywall, taping and painting. Since I had the drywall ripped off, MRS asked for some 120Vac outlets to be moved.

TLDR - The new oven arrived Tuesday afternoon and I "helped" the installer. One project done, three more to go. I'm F'ing exhausted. We were without an oven for 9 weeks. Me working first to repair the old oven, then prepping for the new one. I simply cannot get parts for a 40 year old gas oven. Always wanted a double oven for the Holidays, so time to upgrade.

In the middle of that, the LG washer threw a water valve. I was able to get the part for that and get it fixed.

Septic rooted in and backed up in the basement. Had to get that pumped. Then dry and shampoo the carpets. :sick:

Just three for Thanksgiving and I didn't feel like doing a turkey. Safeway had huge T-Bones 50% off. Heck Yeah! I bought 5. Lo and behold my oldest says he wants to come pick up Miss T and have her over for the extended weekend. Good thing I bought 5 T-Bones. They will stay the night and go back to Oregon Friday morning.

Thanksgiving goes well. We stay up too late catching up.

Friday morning I called my dad. Everyone else is sleeping in. My dad is super depressed and has given up on life. He is asking me about my hunting season and saying he wishes he could still hunt with me. I'm getting depressed too. While I'm talking to my dad I look out the window and Big Hank is cruising for late rut does 100 yards from the house. Definitely wider than his ears and tall. I tell my dad I'm watching this great buck and I should go shoot it. I'm still in my bathrobe.

I hang up with Pop and go grab the .264 out of the safe. I'm in crocs and bathrobe in front of the house. Pretty cold up my knickers. I take a rest off the back of my youngest's Honda Pilot. Chip shot. I can't bring myself to pull the trigger.

The buck moves forward about 20 yards and I move for a better angle, keeping a bull pine between us for cover. I rest on a fence post and I have him at 75 yards broadside. I control my breathing and... Let him walk away into the brush.

I feel pretty old as I walk back into the house and call my dad back. I tell him I gave the buck a pass. He says he probably would too. Maybe there is Karma credit there for when I draw that next moose tag.

Man, I feel you right now, SO much. I've been in the fight of my life this fall trying to save my marriage, our family, and our home, it's not going well. I haven't really had the heart to kill anything other than one grouse, I didn't even bother to pick up an elk tag this fall. I've helped a couple friends out on their hunts for a day or two and went on a couple light hikes with my bow for a deer, but I honestly just don't think I could pull the trigger right now even if I had the chance...
 
Man, I feel you right now, SO much. I've been in the fight of my life this fall trying to save my marriage, our family, and our home, it's not going well. I haven't really had the heart to kill anything other than one grouse, I didn't even bother to pick up an elk tag this fall. I've helped a couple friends out on their hunts for a day or two and went on a couple light hikes with my bow for a deer, but I honestly just don't think I could pull the trigger right now even if I had the chance...
Well Crap.

Hang in there brother. This is one of those posts where you don't know whether this is a "like", a "wow", or an "anger" emoji. PM me if you need someone to listen.
 
Damn! Being able to shoot big Hank off the front porch is like life-goals for me.

Ida shmoked him.

I do recognize the added work on an already full plate, though. Good luck with all of life’s curveballs my friend. Keep that chin held high.
 
If it doesn’t feel right, don’t force it. If you aren’t getting some sort of positive feeling out of the act, whether that’s pride, accomplishment, satisfaction, joy, something, then why do it? There will be other deer on other days. Eventually it will be right.

I think this year/fall has been a struggle for a lot of people. It has been for me. On one hand, glad to know I’m not the only one. On the other, hope everyone is able to persevere through the “stuff” to brighter times.
 
September 15th, 1984. I'm 10 years old, and sitting in the living room waiting for my folks and sister to get ready so we can go out to dinner. Dad walks into the room with a VERY serious look on his face, looks at me, sticks his arm in my direction, and forcefully signs the universally known COME HERE NOW hand gesture. I sheepishly walk into the dining room, and he points out the sliding glass door. I look out and see a buck (WT) that has ~ 150" of decorations on his head... Dad whispers to me, "When I come to full draw, you slowly and quietly slide that door open...
He comes to draw, looks at me and winks, and I start to pull the door open.

At that exact moment, my sister walks into the room, sees Dad with his old bow (Jennings T Star 2) pulled back, me at the door, and looks out the kitchen window, and sees the deer. With no hesitation, she yells "Noooooooooooo!" at the top of her lungs, and the buck bolts, instantly.

Dad comes off of draw, looks at her with a mix of fury and disbelief, not needing to say a word. My sister, unimpressed, looks at Dad and says, "Not on my birthday, we're going to dinner tonight, not skinning deer." She spun on her heel and walked down the hallway, looking for an ally in Mom.

Dad turned to me, smiled, and said, "She's right, but she's lucky I love her."

Sorry to hear you've had a way too busy and stressful fall. Keep swinging.


** Before anyone starts to question the intelligence, safety, and wisdom of the above-described scenario... relax, it was North Idaho in the mid-80s. These people (self included) were much closer to Neanderthals than modern homosapians.
 
September 15th, 1984. I'm 10 years old, and sitting in the living room waiting for my folks and sister to get ready so we can go out to dinner. Dad walks into the room with a VERY serious look on his face, looks at me, sticks his arm in my direction, and forcefully signs the universally known COME HERE NOW hand gesture. I sheepishly walk into the dining room, and he points out the sliding glass door. I look out and see a buck (WT) that has ~ 150" of decorations on his head... Dad whispers to me, "When I come to full draw, you slowly and quietly slide that door open...
He comes to draw, looks at me and winks, and I start to pull the door open.

At that exact moment, my sister walks into the room, sees Dad with his old bow (Jennings T Star 2) pulled back, me at the door, and looks out the kitchen window, and sees the deer. With no hesitation, she yells "Noooooooooooo!" at the top of her lungs, and the buck bolts, instantly.

Dad comes off of draw, looks at her with a mix of fury and disbelief, not needing to say a word. My sister, unimpressed, looks at Dad and says, "Not on my birthday, we're going to dinner tonight, not skinning deer." She spun on her heel and walked down the hallway, looking for an ally in Mom.

Dad turned to me, smiled, and said, "She's right, but she's lucky I love her."

Sorry to hear you've had a way too busy and stressful fall. Keep swinging.


** Before anyone starts to question the intelligence, safety, and wisdom of the above-described scenario... relax, it was North Idaho in the mid-80s. These people (self included) were much closer to Neanderthals than modern homosapians.
When I was 10 one of the windows in the room I shared with my brother had no screen. This so we could ease the .22 out the window to pick ground squirrels off the horse trough.
That trough had a lot of bolt and rubber washer fixes from misses and collateral damage. Every good blind shooter knows if you hold the muzzle back inside the window, you have less chance of getting busted.

The 1960's in California or 1980's in Idaho. Good times to be alive.

Phil Robertson said if you can't pee off your porch, you ain't a free man. We raised three wild Idahoan boys in the 1990's. A golden arc off the balcony was not uncommon.

I personally find the sliding glass door does not make a solid rest unless you open it all the way until it is secure against the stop.
 
Last edited:
Somewhere out there exists a photo of my dad with a very nice mule deer buck taken out of my grandma’s garden from the back deck, the family ranch near the Powder River in Wyoming in the late 70s. I wish I still had the photo.
 
Well Crap.

Hang in there brother. This is one of those posts where you don't know whether this is a "like", a "wow", or an "anger" emoji. PM me if you need someone to listen.
Hang in there. Let me know if you need an ear.

I really appreciate the sentiments fellas, I'll fill you in sometime when I have a minute, sometimes just venting helps...
 
My first thought…


To everything, turn, turn, turn
There is a season, turn, turn, turn
And a time to every purpose under heaven
A time to be born, a time to die
A time to plant, a time to reap
A time to kill, a time to heal
A time to laugh, a time to weep
To everything, turn, turn, turn
There is a season, turn, turn, turn
And a time to every purpose, under heaven


You are right where you are supposed to be. Peace.
 
Every good blind shooter knows if you hold the muzzle back inside the window, you have less chance of getting busted.

True, but it makes it quite a bit louder!

My dad shot a woodchuck out of our living room window with a 30.06 when I was a kid (unbeknownst to my mom who was in the kitchen). Boy did she lose her s$&@…
 

Latest posts

Forum statistics

Threads
117,903
Messages
2,173,263
Members
38,382
Latest member
208Nutt
Back
Top