Best of times or worst of times for elk in eastern mt?

Also, related to the commenter in the news article, it’s not a fair request to make some options only for BMA landowners. BMA isn’t for everyone, and there are still landowners that allow ‘public’ (non-family, sometimes non-friends) hunting not in the BMA program. That’s still access even if it’s not for Joe Hunter.
I appreciate landowners who do allow access independent of bma - a lot - i dont mean to discredit it entirely.

I dont see the parallel between adding an august season and expecting improved success at removing elk from the same areas when the existing several months available to kill them is somehow NOT enough.

As far as the feeling that archery would be improved by shooting at elk with rifles prior to it - thats not been my experience at all. I suppose thats why you mentioned "in a perfect world." The cow elk herds that had been shot at then that i was around were very skiddish compared to normal. Not a fan of that season, or ANY UNLIMITED (quickly commodified is what it should be called) shoulder season in general.
 
I appreciate landowners who do allow access independent of bma - a lot - i dont mean to discredit it entirely.

I dont see the parallel between adding an august season and expecting improved success at removing elk from the same areas when the existing several months available to kill them is somehow NOT enough.

As far as the feeling that archery would be improved by shooting at elk with rifles prior to it - thats not been my experience at all. I suppose thats why you mentioned "in a perfect world." The cow elk herds that had been shot at then that i was around were very skiddish compared to normal. Not a fan of that season, or ANY UNLIMITED (quickly commodified is what it should be called) shoulder season in general.
The proposal for 417 includes a table that shows a history of antlerless elk season structures, average harvest, and elk counts. It’s abundantly clear from that (since it shows only ~30-40 more elk killed per year going from everything limited to unlimited, up to 3 elk/year, late shoulder) that season structure isn’t what’s limiting elk harvest (except in one area).

However, there are some landowners in 417 and other areas that have elk on them June, July, August and those elk move off once the crops are off. An early shoulder gives them the opportunity to rectify that if they so choose. If I had a crystal ball, I also don’t see significant gains on a population- or HD-wide level, but perhaps for one or two landowners struggling with elk damage (who don’t have them later in the year) it will make a difference, and for a few hunters who might not otherwise harvest an elk, it would make a difference. I dunno, I still try to be an idealist..

I’m not personally a fan of early shoulder seasons, but considering there are early shoulder seasons in adjacent/nearby HDs, FWP doesn’t have much to stand on in denying proposing one if a group of landowners happen to come forward with a problem that could partially be rectified and ask for it. The precedent is there, fortunately or unfortunately, depending on how one looks at it.
 
The proposal for 417 includes a table that shows a history of antlerless elk season structures, average harvest, and elk counts. It’s abundantly clear from that (since it shows only ~30-40 more elk killed per year going from everything limited to unlimited, up to 3 elk/year, late shoulder) that season structure isn’t what’s limiting elk harvest (except in one area).
Wow. Thats a stunning rebuke of shoulder seasons in general...

Thanks for the thoughtful response, @WanderWoman - good luck hunting!
 
Wow. Thats a stunning rebuke of shoulder seasons in general...

Thanks for the thoughtful response, @WanderWoman - good luck hunting!
I think it’s a spotlight on how important access is more than anything. “You can have a liberal season but it won’t get you far if the elk aren’t accessible.” I think Captain Obvious has said that a time or two..

A better assessment of shoulder seasons would be looking at the original performance criteria that came out in 2016 or 2018 and stacking that against what is actually happening. Shoulder seasons were meant to supplement general season harvest to help move the dials toward objectives. A rebuke of them or justification for their continuance would be found there, but this is a different FWP and FW Commission than the one in which shoulder seasons were initiated, and the current FW Commission isn’t beholden to past members’ decisions. Or so it’s been said.
 
IMO it doesn’t matter how many tags/seasons people can hunt. There is only so much time and availability for most hunters. There are so many options for tags right now that adding another one will likely have minimal impact. I’m not advocating for it, but if bull hunting was taken off the table until elk populations were lowered, there’d be some cows killed. If Mr Rocket couldn’t get a bull tag until elk populations were in check, I’d bet he’d find a way to kill a bunch of cows…
 
IMO it doesn’t matter how many tags/seasons people can hunt. There is only so much time and availability for most hunters. There are so many options for tags right now that adding another one will likely have minimal impact. I’m not advocating for it, but if bull hunting was taken off the table until elk populations were lowered, there’d be some cows killed. If Mr Rocket couldn’t get a bull tag until elk populations were in check, I’d bet he’d find a way to kill a bunch of cows…
Or better yet - increase the low objective...
 
I think it’s a spotlight on how important access is more than anything. “You can have a liberal season but it won’t get you far if the elk aren’t accessible.” I think Captain Obvious has said that a time or two..

A better assessment of shoulder seasons would be looking at the original performance criteria that came out in 2016 or 2018 and stacking that against what is actually happening. Shoulder seasons were meant to supplement general season harvest to help move the dials toward objectives. A rebuke of them or justification for their continuance would be found there, but this is a different FWP and FW Commission than the one in which shoulder seasons were initiated, and the current FW Commission isn’t beholden to past members’ decisions. Or so it’s been said.
For sure - we could have a thermal equipped machine gun on a helicopter any elk season for 9 months but it wont mean anything if a few of those ranches wont allow access.

I just mean it goes to show how a season/tag means essentially nothing for management and reduction if some access isnt changed. Fwp cant and never will be able to settle major wildlfie management differences between different landowners and more tags and longer seasons wont help.

Maybe that'll be finally settled in montanas supreme court since upoms lawsuit is still pending there.
 
For sure - we could have a thermal equipped machine gun on a helicopter any elk season for 9 months but it wont mean anything if a few of those ranches wont allow access.

I just mean it goes to show how a season/tag means essentially nothing for management and reduction if some access isnt changed. Fwp cant and never will be able to settle major wildlfie management differences between different landowners and more tags and longer seasons wont help.

Maybe that'll be finally settled in montanas supreme court since upoms lawsuit is still pending there
FWP already manages as if they win the lawsuit (which currently they did). The only thing that will change is if UPOM wins the appeal.
 
I’ll say it again, make all these units antlerless harvest only until numbers are brought to objective. Landowner will either let people actually kill the problem elk or this manufactured problem will magically go away and they’ll be content with numbers how they are.

But I see this continuing to be one big circle jerk until the wealthy landowners get their way. Transferrable landowner permits or general bull hunting
 
That’s been an option on the table for decades. Not many have the stones to do it.

I agree, the problem would remedy itself.
I don’t think it would. My money is the residents fold first because the guy with the money for ranches like that would probably just laugh while having their jet fueled up to go hunt elk in Nevada.
 
I’ll say it again, make all these units antlerless harvest only until numbers are brought to objective. Landowner will either let people actually kill the problem elk or this manufactured problem will magically go away and they’ll be content with numbers how they are.

But I see this continuing to be one big circle jerk until the wealthy landowners get their way. Transferrable landowner permits or general bull hunting
That’s been an option on the table for decades. Not many have the stones to do it.

I agree, the problem would remedy itself.
I wish it were this simple. No way, no how in the current political landscape. And while at a certain level it would work, you know how people get when they think something is punitive…

I would also bet that in today’s era of easy-to-draw limited-entry archery permits and how used to that people are, and how little success regional staff have had in tempering that relative to accessible lands and crowding complaints, it’d be harder to convince local archers to give up bull hunting opportunity than it would MT residents their mule deer rut hunt.
 
Last edited:
[QUOTE="WanderWoman, post: 4101989, member: 43685 it’d be harder to convince local archers to give up bull hunting opportunity than you would MT residents their mule deer rut hunt.
[/QUOTE]
I agree. And the archery free for all in the Breaks is impacting the bull hunting in a bad way. mtmuley
 
FWP needs a round table discussion with landowners housing huge numbers of elk and work a solution out to reduce cow numbers. A private land only cow tag, make last week or 2(?) cow only. See what kind of response and harvest there is. Maybe make last 3 weeks of season cow only, whatever it takes to get numbers in check.
Now someone figure out the incentive to the landowners to allow the public in to harvest. Harvest would have to be monitored and controlled.
 
FWP needs a round table discussion with landowners housing huge numbers of elk and work a solution out to reduce cow numbers. A private land only cow tag, make last week or 2(?) cow only. See what kind of response and harvest there is. Maybe make last 3 weeks of season cow only, whatever it takes to get numbers in check.
Now someone figure out the incentive to the landowners to allow the public in to harvest. Harvest would have to be monitored and controlled.

You know what ideas come out of those meeting? Being able to kill cows 365 days a year…
 
I would also bet that in today’s era of easy-to-draw limited-entry archery permits and how used to that people are, and how little success regional staff have had in tempering that relative to accessible lands and crowding complaints, it’d be harder to convince local archers to give up bull hunting opportunity than it would MT residents their mule deer rut hunt.

Yep, hunters would fight it tooth and nail too. They’d rather keep the status quo than try something radical that could make some meaningful change.

The only way to see a side’s true motives is to throw out a nuclear option. Until that happens, we’ll always be fed lies
 
Yep, hunters would fight it tooth and nail too. They’d rather keep the status quo than try something radical that could make some meaningful change.

The only way to see a side’s true motives is to throw out a nuclear option. Until that happens, we’ll always be fed lies
Its ironic - cause if more of those tags were 2/3 year cycles instead of near gaurantee - thered probably be a lot better access and less potential for leasing.
 

Latest posts

Forum statistics

Threads
120,544
Messages
2,263,260
Members
39,141
Latest member
GarciaBoy
Back
Top