As bear opens

[Idaho_Smiley]

Here is a bear my buddy will be looking to improve upon it went 21" 11/16th and that was after 6 months of drying.

 

[Big Fin]

Smiley:

That's a great bear. Hopefully he gets that thing officially scored, if he hasn't already. The ID state record is 21 10/16.

If you guys improve on that one, you will have one hell of a whopper.

 

[GatoMan]

actually 22 2/16th is the state record, if that bear is what smiley says it would be ranked 3rd, personally it don't look it to me.

 

[idhuntingfool]

hey shane glad to see your around sorry i never did get you called for lions, going through a divorce and all that crap and i dont know where my life is headed but i do have a bear tag you interested in going out and popping my cherry for bears?

 

[shoots-straight]

What an absolute Giant of a Bear. My first response was WOW! I've hunted them all my life and that bear was what's been in my dreams. Congrates to your buddy.

 

[Idaho_Smiley]

21 11/16th is what it is I allways hear of them but when I see them measured they are being measured wrong . I watched it measured and the calipers were used corectly I cannot imagine it being off by more than a hair.
I was not there on this one but the one he killed the year before less than a mile away is over 20" also.
He did say he is having it entered in the books.

 

[Moosie]

Toad !!!!!!!!!!!!!

 

[Big Fin]

actually 22 2/16th is the state record, if that bear is what smiley says it would be ranked 3rd, personally it don't look it to me.

Gato, if that is the case, then B&C needs to update thier "trophy search" records database. I have copied it from their site.

Regardless, Smiley's buddy shot one hell of a bear.

World Record is 23 10/16 from Sanpete County, UT



SCORE LOCATION HUNTER OWNER DATE RANK


1. 21 10/16 Custer, ID Robert L. Caskey Robert L. Caskey 1967 261


2. 21 8/16 Bonneville, ID George R. Adams George R. Adams 1982 343


3. 21 6/16 Sandpoint, ID Ronald L. Book Ronald L. Book 1969 460


4. 21 4/16 Nez Perce, ID Nick G. Manfull Nick G. Manfull 2003 587


5. 21 3/16 Idaho, ID Dustin G. Derrick Dustin G. Derrick 2004 658


6. 21 2/16 Caribou, ID Ronald J. Thompson Ronald J. Thompson 1986 735


7. 21 2/16 Nez Perce, ID Brice J. Barnes Brice J. Barnes 1998 735


8. 20 12/16 Boise, ID Charles S. Barto Charles S. Barto 1988 1198


9. 20 11/16 Idaho, ID Bernard E. Patynski Bernard E. Patynski 1998 1245


10. 20 10/16 Lewis, ID Bradley J. Zenner Bradley J. Zenner 2003 1290


11. 20 10/16 Bonneville, ID Adrian N. McConeghy Adrian N. McConeghy 1999 1290


12. 20 9/16 Caribou, ID Travis G. Ostler Travis G. Ostler 2005 1331


13. 20 9/16 Idaho, ID Rickey M. Davis Rickey M. Davis 1998 1331


14. 20 8/16 Boise, ID Rodney L. Pylican Rodney L. Pylican 2000 1382


15. 20 7/16 Boise, ID Gordon B. Richins Gordon B. Richins 1993 1451


16. 20 7/16 Nez Perce, ID Chris Brown Chris Brown 1998 1451


17. 20 6/16 Nez Perce, ID Dirk T. Williams Dirk T. Williams 2000 1519


18. 20 5/16 Idaho, ID Stanley M. Dahl Stanley M. Dahl 1993 1616


19. 20 5/16 Idaho, ID Tina M. Mattice Tina M. Mattice 1999 1616


20. 20 5/16 Nez Perce, ID Gregory L. Bryant Gregory L. Bryant 1999 1616


21. 20 4/16 Caribou, ID Andrew J. Ford Andrew J. Ford 1998 1691


22. 20 4/16 Latah, ID Gary S. BeVan, Jr. Gary S. BeVan, Jr. 1995 1691


23. 20 4/16 Camas, ID Archie E. Malone Archie E. Malone 1992 1691


24. 20 4/16 Teton, ID Kirk L. Reynolds Kirk L. Reynolds 2005 1691


25. 20 3/16 Idaho, ID Shayne R. Ellis Shayne R. Ellis 2001 1783


26. 20 3/16 Clearwater, ID Dana L. Lott Dana L. Lott 1995 1783


27. 20 2/16 Idaho, ID Robert J. Kaminski Robert J. Kaminski 1990 1853


28. 20 2/16 Latah, ID Patrick M. McCullough Patrick M. McCullough 1990 1853


29. 20 1/16 Nez Perce, ID Sean M. Wilson Sean M. Wilson 2002 1940


30. 20 1/16 Boise, ID Michael C. Lower Michael C. Lower 2002 1940


31. 20 1/16 Idaho, ID Daniel D. Drover Daniel D. Drover 2003 1940


32. 20 Clearwater, ID Nathan Manfull Nathan Manfull 2004 2013


33. 20 Valley, ID Darwin G. DeCroo Darwin G. DeCroo 2003 2013


34. 20 Madison, ID Stetson T. Perry Stetson T. Perry 2006 2013


35. 20 Idaho, ID David C. Huber, Sr. David C. Huber, Sr. 1988 2013


36. 20 Benewah, ID Richard E. Rainbolt Richard E. Rainbolt 1996 2013

 

[Point Creep]

There isn't a bear-expert wannbe out there that can guess a bear's skull size within an inch from a photo like that. I can tell it's certainly no cub and I hope I shoot one like that sometime..

 

[IdahoBugler]

That thing looks like a toad to me. I'd love to shoot something like that.

 

[Idaho_Smiley]

Well my guess when I saw the bear was 20 8/16th , I did not think it would go over 21. I thought it was like his the year before and was 20 8/16th .
2 years and 2 bears over 20" pretty good huh.
Bear two years ago was 350ish and this bear was over 400 he squared over 7foot

 

[Point Creep]

Let me see if I got this right, you guys are looking at bears alive and estimating skull size to the sixteenth of an inch?

 

[brymoore]

GH - I think they scored it, not doing a visual guess. He talks about drying the skull for six months.

 

[GatoMan]

Big fin, check idaho fish and games website to find idaho state records...... its a nice bear no doubt, but on another website the actual hunter even quoted to smiley that it has'nt been officially scored so smiley saying what it is and he was there etc, etc, who knows. Nice bear non the less.....

 

[Idaho_Smiley]

Not skull size with the bear still attached at all. And Gato man the bears skull was just down the road 2 miles from my house I go to mikes pretty often to talk to him.
I watched it measured and when Nate says official he means by a liscenced or whatever boone and crocket judge. I garuntee it will not be off much.
gATO YOU GOT A PROBLEM SAY IT SAY IT BUT DO NOT IMPLY i WAS LYING smiley saying what it is and he was there etc, etc, who knows.AS YOU DID HERE If I took it wrong sorry