I had a similar bad experience last year, but not nearly as long. I shot a Muley buck in velvet with my bow two falls ago, and I’m just a euro mount guy, but I wanted a taxidermist to preserve the velvet.
Found a guy in Missoula who seemed legit. Had a shop with lots of mounts and stuff he was working on. No red flags other than him being socially awkward, but hey maybe that’s why he likes to work with dead animals.
He gives me a six month timeline to clean the skull and preserve the velvet. Six months go by, nothing. I start just by emailing. Another month, and I call and leave a voicemail. Soon I start texting. No responses never answers. At about ten months, I went to his house/shop. Not home, wife answers the door. Doesn’t know what to tell me, and I didn’t want to make her uncomfortable by insisting to see the shop. After this visit he finally texts me. Makes BS excuses about the beetles taking a long time, and with this I knew something was off. This turned into more text excuses over the next few months.
Finally, 14 months later, he spills the beans. He ruined the skull early on when trying to boil it after something happened with his beetles. Couldn’t bring himself to tell me I guess? Put the antlers (with velvet thankfully) on an artificial skull, gave it to me with my deposit back.
Sorry for the long story. The moral is, GO TO HIS DAMN SHOP! And I’d be ready to be massively disappointed that something is wrong with your deer. That way if it’s not, you’ll be pleasantly surprised.