Video on Montana's Mule Deer Management

That is a fine opinion to have. In some ways i agree but not in everyway. It doesnt really matter - the opinion meaningfully doesnt address the core point:

Your quality of hunt would meaningfully with 2x the NR deer hunters you have. Independent of season structure.

It’s a fact independent of your opinion. Two things can be true at once.

The deer hunting would be better with fewer hunters, not fewer NR hunters.

You know what would make it even better than that? Not unlimited rut hunting. And it would do more than cutting out the NRs, I’m sure.
 
Hey now - theres several thousand paying customers giddy to shoot the first 160" mule deer they see..... Colorado sells around 16.5k (all nr deer tags, b included). Montana sells more double that to people not living here.

Its not hard to see across the west the quality of hunt, animals, and access is influenced a lot by NR tag sales.

I think MT sells more buck rut tags to Residents than CO sells deer tags in entirety.. Not sure how that balances out with total buck rut tags, but id guess at least 5x more isn't out of the question.

So I wont argue against Montana limiting or distributing NR pressure more, but you could eliminate all NR and the season structure your residents demand would still have MT significantly lagging CO in hunt quality.

Colorado gives a higher percentage of its tags to non-residents than montana. It's just fewer because they actually manage deer a bit.
 
Last edited:
I think MT sells more buck rut tags to Residents than CO sells deer tags in entirety.. Not sure how that balances out with total buck rut tags, but id guess at least 5x more isn't out of the question.

So while I wont argue against Montana limiting or distributing NR pressure more, but you could eliminate all NR and the season structure your residents demand would still have MT significantly lagging CO in hunt quality.

Colorado gives a higher percentage of its tags to non-residents than montana. It's just fewer because they actually manage deer a bit.
Correct.
 
I think MT sells more buck rut tags to Residents than CO sells deer tags in entirety.. Not sure how that balances out with total buck rut tags, but id guess at least 5x more isn't out of the question.

So while I wont argue against Montana limiting or distributing NR pressure more, but you could eliminate all NR and the season structure your residents demand would still have MT significantly lagging CO in hunt quality.

Colorado gives a higher percentage of its tags to non-residents than montana. It's just fewer because they actually manage deer a bit.
R tag sales are a very poor metric for hunting pressure when tags are so cheap. A healthy percentage dont meaningfully get hunted.

Id suggest looking at harvest rate percentage if you are looking to understand what tag sales are leading to harvest and/or pressure.
 
The deer hunting would be better with fewer hunters, not fewer NR hunters.

You know what would make it even better than that? Not unlimited rut hunting.
Im fine with limiting the rut hunting. Not related to my point.
 
Im fine with limiting the rut hunting. Not related to my point.

Your point was this: "Its not hard to see across the west the quality of hunt, animals, and access is influenced a lot by NR tag sales."

It's a patently false claim. Our NR tag sales have absolutely nothing to do with our quality. In fact, we could cut NR tags to zero and it wouldn't change the number of hunters on the landscape and it would negligibly change the number of deer killed, if at all.

Our quality is predominantly determined by our season structure and habitat.
 
R tag sales are a very poor metric for hunting pressure when tags are so cheap. A healthy percentage dont meaningfully get hunted.

Id suggest looking at harvest rate percentage if you are looking to understand what tag sales are leading to harvest and/or pressure.

I dont think you'll find much disagreement that there are regional outsized NR impacts that should be addressed.

It's just the blanket comparison to CO that fell flat since they issue a higher percentage of tags to NR. The difference is CO actually manages where and when NR hunt.
 
Back
Top