Public land friend-ethics

Similar deal happened when I was young like you look to be, found a primo musky lake with one friend, we each took another friend, I took family, and in a couple years it was a mad house and the entire local fishing club was there every weekend (3 hours drive from home). Turned into a royal circus! It sucks, and I think we all learn as we go in life. Since then my circle has gotten quite small, one small crew that shares fishn stuff, one real small crew that shares huntn stuff. I pretty much wont take anyone to an area if I'm not OK with them telling their friends cuz I know they will anyway, even if you ask them not to. I trusted a guy from church last year and that even bit me, guess I am still a slow learner. Sadly you are just going to have to put the total ignore to C and hope he gets the hint, or flat out tell him that you think 4 guys is enough, which in my opinion seems like 1 too many already. Best wishes!!
 
In your scenario, I get that you don't want to take C back there with you guys in the future. But are there other hunts you guys are willing to do with him? Or is it that you just don't want to do travel hunts with him period? I think it makes a difference if you're telling him we want to keep this hunt for ourselves, but we can find another place that can be "our" (C, you, and whoever) trip, vs. we don't want to do hunting trips with you at all. Might mean the difference between keeping or losing him as a friend. Depends on how you feel about the friendship as a whole I guess.


I would be willing to go on another hunt with him... eventually... Lots of friends that have mentioned (politely and less intrusively) that if there is room on a trip, or if they could plan a hunt with me/us someday, they would be interested.

I know, I know, part of life. The balancing act is a tricky one
 
I have a couple friends that sound like C. I typically either don't mention I'm going on trips that I don't want him to go on, or tell him it's someone else's trip and I just got invited, or the very first time I mention it for the year I go out of my way to lay it all out there.

Are you guys all friends or are you the center of the wheel and the "spokes" aren't friends with each other? If that's the case I politely throw someone else under the bus. BFF really just want to do a small trip to a new area. I'll report back what we find...


Haha, I've used that tactic a time or two.

Generally, we're all friends, but there are certain guys we're each closer with, so unfortunately, and BFF and I have discussed it already, that we may have to plan separate trips. Hard decision to make, since we're basically one mind when we hunt together... or in general. We've been best friends since kindergarten, but it would be a good way to kill a couple birds with multiple stones.
 
Sounds like a friend issue, not a public land issue. If he really is your friend, take him. Tell him in the past he's been hard to be around for any length of time, and if he is an ass on this trip it will be the last time he gets an invite. If he's not really your friend tell him to go pound sand.

I learned the hard way on this. I took a buddy from work hunting and now his whole family hunts the drainage I showed him. I have two very close friends, and a handful of family members (wife included) that know where I kill elk now.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
I would rather have two or three hunting buddies I trust to handle firearms correctly, not give up on the hunt, like to laugh around the evening campfire, help chop firewood, etc than a dozen "small dose" acquaintances that take away from the adventure. Sure, they might be fine to go out for a drink or a day or two of quail hunting but not for a week to ten days of togetherness.

Life is too short to suffer fools on your days off of work. You can be a tactful or direct as you want but do not allow someone on your adventure that makes you regret the trip from the moment you are pulling over to fill up the gas tank on Day 1.

Cull the herd. Your adventure will be more enjoyable.
 
What he said!

I would rather have two or three hunting buddies I trust to handle firearms correctly, not give up on the hunt, like to laugh around the evening campfire, help chop firewood, etc than a dozen "small dose" acquaintances that take away from the adventure. Sure, they might be fine to go out for a drink or a day or two of quail hunting but not for a week to ten days of togetherness.

Life is too short to suffer fools on your days off of work. You can be a tactful or direct as you want but do not allow someone on your adventure that makes you regret the trip from the moment you are pulling over to fill up the gas tank on Day 1.

Cull the herd. Your adventure will be more enjoyable.
 

Latest posts

Forum statistics

Threads
117,916
Messages
2,173,763
Members
38,383
Latest member
HeyCoop
Back
Top