Nov 3 - Independents’ Day?

We were talking about the House Seat, right?
On the other hand, I feel like most people move to Montana to escape the politics of other states like CA, WA, and OR. Sure, some are buying second homes, but those people don't really count since they probably aren't legally voting here and where their primary home is. Some are moving for the beauty, but there are other states for that. Of course, those second homes are still driving the prices up which hurts those who don't already have a home.
I thought we were talking about the state of Montana politics and the perceived rightward shoft from transplants.
 
I thought we were talking about the state of Montana politics and the perceived rightward shoft from transplants.
... and a million other things. The thread which is very out of date at this point has jumped around quite a lot.
 
That's just your assumption. If it was deep red, Tester and Bullock would have never been elected.
Well, you keep arguing but changing your position into convoluted incoherent ramblings rather than just outright saying what you mean. Though I guess that is troll strategy number 1 and I fell for it. Nice work 🤣
 
Well, you keep arguing but changing your position into convoluted incoherent ramblings rather than just outright saying what you mean. Though I guess that is troll strategy number 1 and I fell for it. Nice work 🤣
I haven't changed a position, but I can understand you being confused on a thread like this one. It is hard to follow.
 
Perhaps, but he did get away with it.
Because Montanans are no longer as independent as they claim. Dude could have suggested a telephone pole take his place and it would have won as long at it leaned to the right. The article made some things clear and left some things out. Dems tried to get Bodnar to run as a Dem, he chose to run as an independent. Bankhead ran under the Dem banner with little if any support from "the Party" and funding from just one big PAC. Right-leaning PACs ran anti-Bodnar adds on left-leaning positions to divide the vote, and succeeded (probably a waste of money IMO). Bankhead was stubborn and refused to drop out (as we saw across the country, most politicians have a healthy ego to feed). Most voters are too lazy to do any real research on candidates and just revert to the letter next to the name.
 
Because Montanans are no longer as independent as they claim.
I think it was because simultaneously, Ds shot themselves in the foot by running their strongest D as an I. Sure, there were a few people who didn't want to vote for the ordained R because it was sketchy.

I expect the I to run as a D for Governor for 2028. We'll see.
 
I think it was because simultaneously, Ds shot themselves in the foot by running their strongest D as an I. Sure, there were a few people who didn't want to vote for the ordained R because it was sketchy.

I expect the I to run as a D for Governor for 2028. We'll see.
Either way he isn’t getting your vote. You are what you are and you’re not changing.
 
For Bodnar in particular, his stances based on UM President documented in his messages is enough for anyone except Lefties.

There is no way he could win as an R in a primary even against a Rino. I'll never to choose between him as the "R" or the D.
Im betting your only struggle would be if Tucker Carlson ran as an Independent in 2028.
 
The way things broke down suggests it would have been a tight race.
Maybe, but the numbers over various years tell you a lot about the voters. I am very confident it didn't matter. Most of the voters couldn't pick Alme out of a one-man lineup.

edit: He was told that The Dem brand was toxic in Montana. And he was told that he would never win as an independent. Both of those things are true. Simply adding together two sets of voters and claiming it would have been competitive is an oversimplification, but easy math.
 
Simply adding together two sets of voters and claiming it would have been competitive is an oversimplification, but easy math.

I agree with that- just because the math looks juicy in hindsight, that’s not necessarily how that would have played out. We’ll never know.

As for the Dem brand being too toxic in Montana, I would have agreed with that a few months ago. But the way the national election went as a whole makes me suspect the MAGA brand is even worse. It was in Texas and Mississippi, no reason to think Montana was impossible.

IMO he bet on the wrong horse trying the Independent route, but part of me admires him for trying. I suspect we’ll hear his name again sometime in the next few years.
 
The election was largely a repudiation of Trump and MAGA. It was not the voters deciding that Democrats are wonderful. It is a binary choice, the election victory was a mix of, voters liking Democrats, and voters rejecting Trump's MAGA movement.

Time will tell if Democratic politicians read their win, accurately or not. With Trump doubling down, after the election, it will cause more erosion in his support. GOP political survivors have some big decisions to make about when to jump ship, or stay the course, with Trump.

I asked my wife this morning how likely Trump's meeting with Putin and XI would benefit our country. She wasn't confident it would be. I think they will have him for lunch.
 
The binary choice of our 2 party 'system' was florid in this election. It keeps resulting in long arc pendulum swings in our politics. Much gets undone with each swing, little gets done. Independents could keep our political attention in the middle ground between the two party extremes, they would if their constituents were strong enough to force it. Many complain our 2 parties are too similar, except for their extremes. Is that a fault, or possible common ground to take us forward instead of riding a teeter totter that goes up and down but never really moves? Independents and/or a viable 3rd party could do that. The blue tsunami is a short-term relief to me and some others, an existential threat to the rest. But in reality is is more of the same us-vs-them, political stagnation or worse.
 
Back
Top