Never bone out shoulder again

Do any of you all have a written recipe, please? Thank you!
my last one:

- Whole shoulder, with or without shank
(recipe would be good with eqivalent quantity of shanks or brisket)
- Coat in light oil and Costco taco seasoning or similar
- Grill or smoke briefly to brown/get surface char.
- Lay in deep roasting pan or tray
- 1 can tomato sauce or + for x-large
-1 can diced or crushed tomato or +
- 1 can Rotel
-3 Tbs Sofrito base
-1 can black olive
-1 can garbanzos
- A packet or equivalent of taco seasoning.

You can add green or red olives, corn, onions, peppers, tomatoes, capers, etc if you have them

cover meat with all the sauces and bake/roast at around 325 for maybe 4-5 hours or as low as 200 for 12+hours. Shred meat off bones and remove bones. It’s not always an exact science. If meat is still tough, turn over, re cover in sauce and keep cooking until it falls apart. Just keep covered and moist. Trust that it WILL get tender, shreddable, and fall off the bone. Don’t force it.

Use on tortillas or shells with whatever fixins you prefer.

This method could easily be modified to a BBQ pulled venison, or sloppy joe recipe. You can add a coke, dr pepper, whiskey, wine or a beer to the sauce, or really whatever the hell you like.
 
Last edited:
Since it is just me and the wife at home, a shoulder leaves leftovers. Tacos, burritos and in rice. But more left. This time I chopped up all the leftover meat and veggies and mixed with beans and another can of diced tomatoes. Chili kind of but not Texas style. Amazing. mtmuley
 
I was looking at the front shoulder of the WY Muley I lust brought home and remembered this thread. Gonna give it a try.
thank you
Have a pronghorn shoulder in the marinade right now...taking it to elk camp.

 
Have a pronghorn shoulder in the marinade right now...taking it to elk camp.


I'll give it a try.

My WY Elk hunt only lasted a few hours, small herd thought 400 yards from a hwy was a good spot to stand.
 

Latest posts

Forum statistics

Threads
117,711
Messages
2,165,803
Members
38,326
Latest member
sensortech2A1
Back
Top