Is too late to start from 0 for goats, sheep and moose in any western state?

Scott85

Active member
Joined
Nov 22, 2018
Messages
271
Is it too late to start from 0 for points in any western state? I'm 33 and in great health so I would like to think I have at least to the age of 65-70 of playing around in the mountains before I need to hang up. If it isn't too late what would be a good state to start in. I'm not discounting the unlimits in MT. Thanks for the help!!
 

dirtytough

New member
Joined
Jan 4, 2018
Messages
38
Is it too late to start from 0 for points in any western state? I'm 33 and in great health so I would like to think I have at least to the age of 65-70 of playing around in the mountains before I need to hang up. If it isn't too late what would be a good state to start in. I'm not discounting the unlimits in MT. Thanks for the help!!
That’s a tough call. If you have a bunch of extra money it might be worth it. Wyoming is about $500 a year to apply for moose, sheep, and goat. No points for goat. Colorado is a little over $400 to apply for all 3. Montana is around $250.

The thing is there are guys that are the same age as you but started in their teens. So don’t expect to ever have the most points. Also states are going to keep upping the price. Example Wyoming and Colorado this year.

Idaho there aren’t any points. So it’s a level playing field every year. Same in New Mexico.

Honestly looking at the numbers of over $1k a year to apply for just 3 states moose, sheep, and goat I think a guy just starting out is money ahead to save as much as possible, invest it, and buy the tags he wants.

Idaho is probably worth applying. It’s about $200 a year and you can only apply for 1 species. But the odds of drawing are pretty good compared to other states.
 

Pelican

Active member
Joined
Apr 24, 2018
Messages
206
Location
Fruita, Colorado
i am not familiar with the odds in all states, but in general I don’t think you would be guaranteed to draw within even 30 years. You can draw without max points in some states (Utah, Colorado, others) but it is extremely unlikely but it does happen. Idaho and New Mexico don’t have point systems so you have an equal chance as other non residents.
 

BlakeA

Well-known member
Joined
Dec 13, 2012
Messages
1,480
Location
North Dakota
You would be better off taking a drive and throwing your money out the window dollar by dollar and letting the wind take it. At least you would get a nice car ride out of it and perhaps grab a bite to eat before it's all gone.
 

fulldraw

Member
Joined
Jul 8, 2012
Messages
448
Location
Iowa
You would be better off taking a drive and throwing your money out the window dollar by dollar and letting the wind take it. At least you would get a nice car ride out of it and perhaps grab a bite to eat before it's all gone.
You have to love the humor in this response .LOL
 

Zim

Member
Joined
Dec 4, 2011
Messages
590
Location
LaPorte, IN
You would be better off taking a drive and throwing your money out the window dollar by dollar and letting the wind take it. At least you would get a nice car ride out of it and perhaps grab a bite to eat before it's all gone.
Sadly, that's about what it's coming to. I am 59 and started 23 years ago. Just got a couple moose hunts out of it. As the nonrefundable fees jacked over the years, I abandoned points and walked away from all but one, CO sheep. And now my slim chance there is becoming none thanks to their rule change. All I can say is I'm glad I limited my losses. Could have been a lot worse. As dt pointed out, if you have a ton of coin, you still might consider it. But otherwise no way I'd buy in at the ground floor with the current systems. Unfortunately, all states only care about bringing wealthy hunters to their states. They really have no interest in average Joe Hunter. If I were you at your age, I'd just save and settle for a Canadian moose or caribou hunt. Maybe get some walleye fishing out of the trip as well.
 

Scott85

Active member
Joined
Nov 22, 2018
Messages
271
Sadly, that's about what it's coming to. I am 59 and started 23 years ago. Just got a couple moose hunts out of it. As the nonrefundable fees jacked over the years, I abandoned points and walked away from all but one, CO sheep. And now my slim chance there is becoming none thanks to their rule change. All I can say is I'm glad I limited my losses. Could have been a lot worse. As dt pointed out, if you have a ton of coin, you still might consider it. But otherwise no way I'd buy in at the ground floor with the current systems. Unfortunately, all states only care about bringing wealthy hunters to their states. They really have no interest in average Joe Hunter. If I were you at your age, I'd just save and settle for a Canadian moose or caribou hunt. Maybe get some walleye fishing out of the trip as well.
What would you consider "a ton of coin"? by no way am I rich but I do have some disposable income that can be devoted solely for hunting.
 

NoWiser

Well-known member
Joined
Feb 12, 2013
Messages
1,284
Location
Minnesota
You are about 21 years too late. You’ll forever be behind the guys your age (and younger) whose parents started getting them points at 12 years old.
 

PrairieHunter

Active member
Joined
May 17, 2018
Messages
948
Location
Laramie, WY
If you truly love sheep and want to hunt them you will find a way to be around them even if you don't have a tag.

I have found that there are 2 types of sheep guys.
The ones who love sheep and spend time in sheep country on a regular basis without tags.
And then there are the guys who rarely if ever sleep anywhere close to sheep country and simply want a picture of themselves next to a dead sheep to show people.
 

Buschy

Well-known member
Joined
Jan 1, 2001
Messages
1,280
Location
Colorado
It goes without saying sheep tags are tough. My approach has been to apply, not worry about it, and maybe lighting will strike. This year it did for me. I drew CO with 3+0. You can't draw if you don't apply.
 

Bluejeep

Active member
Joined
Jan 31, 2018
Messages
265
Location
Billings, MT
I'm in the same boat with you, but I'm 35. I have choose not to build points for any of the big 3 and just stick to states with a random draw. I will be doing the Unlimited as much as I can though
 

NoWiser

Well-known member
Joined
Feb 12, 2013
Messages
1,284
Location
Minnesota
Just with Wyoming’s fees alone, in a few years you could do a DIY moose hunt in Ontario. You need to go through an outfitter but you could still hunt on your own. Just a thought.
 

ashersdad

Well-known member
Joined
Feb 8, 2007
Messages
2,899
Location
Portland, OR
I had to make that decision recently for my 14 and 12 year old. After doing my research I decided that for them I would just bank money every year and just put in for the states that don’t have points. I realize people get lucky and you can’t draw if you don’t put in but I have a lot of points in states that I will likely never draw and I don’t want my kids to be stuck in the same situation 20 years from now.

My other concern is the number of tags in 20-30 years. When I drew moose in Utah 9 years ago there were 27 tags for the unit. Last year there were 8. I also drew moose in Wyoming years ago and same thing. Dramatically less tags today.

My goal for my kids is to hunt deer and elk every year, antelope as often as possible, and if they end up wanting moose, sheep, or goat, we’ll have saved up money to hopefully buy a tag somewhere or get lucky in a state that doesn't have points.
 

TheGrayRider

Active member
Joined
Jan 3, 2014
Messages
101
Location
Indiana
Apply for mountain goat hunts in Alaska. No point system and not too expensive for the draw each year. Won’t bankrupt you. You will draw in the near future while you still have your youth. I drew in only seven years. Don’t listen to the naysayers or spend time with negative people. Hit the damn mountain. Good luck!
 

Scott85

Active member
Joined
Nov 22, 2018
Messages
271
Apply for mountain goat hunts in Alaska. No point system and not too expensive for the draw each year. Won’t bankrupt you. You will draw in the near future while you still have your youth. I drew in only seven years. Don’t listen to the naysayers or spend time with negative people. Hit the damn mountain. Good luck!
How much did the guide cost for the goat hunt?
 

brownbear932008

Well-known member
Joined
Jul 15, 2011
Messages
1,571
Location
Abingdon VA.
LOL I have quite the points now and still feel it's a bottomless pit. Not kidding either. My advise don't get in the point game save your bucks and go to alaska for goat Newfoundland for moose and sheep well that's a pricey one either way. But I'd go chase dall in Alaska if I had it to do over years ago when it was somewhat affordable. But you can spend a lot of money in the lower 48 chasing that dream of .001% odds.

Edit don't over look state raffles super tags draws and such. Terrible odds but cheap to throw your name in the hat.
 
Last edited:

Flatrock

Well-known member
Joined
Dec 1, 2010
Messages
1,298
Location
Bismarck, ND
You would be better off taking a drive and throwing your money out the window dollar by dollar and letting the wind take it. At least you would get a nice car ride out of it and perhaps grab a bite to eat before it's all gone.
Blasphemy. That's not what you told me earlier this week! Are you trying to bankrupt me or what!?!?

I absolutely would not start applying if I were you. I'm 34 with 7-9 points in a few states and am not sure it's worth it for me to continue. I felt it was worth it a few years ago when it wasn't nearly as expensive in CO and WY. 3 years ago, it probably cost me roughly $210 or so to apply for and get points for the big 3 in those 2 states (minus mountain goat in WY). This year, I think it'll cost me roughly $750 if I apply for everything. That's getting pretty ridiculous.

I'd say decide what you would REALLY like to hunt and then just save for that. Moose/mountain goat hunts aren't too outrageous in Canada or Alaska. No they're not cheap, but doable if you saved $500-1,000 a year. Sheep is just tough. Either need to be super lucky to draw a lottery tag or else pay up big money to do it. A MT ewe hunt would be something to think about. I know a few years ago, you could draw one of those tags in 3-5 years or so. I'd honestly like to do that some year.

Also, the Idaho odds are not nearly as good as they look on paper. The 10% allocation to NR puts them down in the 1-5% range.
 
Top