Gastro Gnome - Eat Better Wherever

California blacktails

Jumping in this thread a little late but could not help myself. I'm an East Coast Guy that grew up hunting Whitetails in NH and MA then later on in NC. I moved to the Eastern Sierras for work last summer and tried my hand at Mule Deer/Black Tail hunting this last season and now I'm hooked. Like other guys said above, CA is not typically grouped with the traditional Western States but I would argue it ranks right up there in beauty and opportunities. The availability of species and overall size isn't the same but it is still an absolute great place to hunt.

I hunt the D3-D5 zones (OTC) right in the heart of the Sierras. It’s a pretty cool area because on the Eastern side of the zone you can catch mixed conifers with High Desert Sage brush (Mainly where I hunt) and the Western side is more large conifer forests. From what I have been told, the Mulies favor the east and you are more likely to find the Blacktails on the west. Like anywhere, I encountered fairly heavy pressure from the Jeep/4Wheeler crowd right off the roads but with some walking was able to get miles to myself.

I shot this guy on the 2nd to last weekend of the season and there was a slightly smaller buck about 10 yards behind him. I have not got any scientific verification or opinion but the taxidermist thought he might be a Muley/Blacktail hybrid.

What does the tail look like? Awesome buck btw..
 
I hunted CA for 24 years until moving to Idaho. I go back to hunt pigs annually with a friend, on a ranch near salinas.

Growing up I hunted unit D3-5, because I lived there. To set anyones expectation that the hunting there was good would be a real mischaracterization. It's no misprint, the single digit success rates. I can tell you that the number of bucks in that zone that are over 3 years old would also be in the single digits, and buck to doe ratios are in the 10-15% range as well. That said the country is beautiful, but not full of deer.

The foothills, which is exclusively private ranches, is where the majority of the deer live.

The majority of deer on the Easter half of the state, except the extreme NE corner, and truely on the E side of the Sierra's, are more Blacktail than Muley, and all are considered mixed per B&C. I believe anything killed W of I-5 is considered a true blacktail. Funny thing about little blacktails, you can kill a 5 year old buck and it can still be a forkey.

Understand, California has not allowed Mt Lions to be hunted for probably 40 years or more. That is not a good thing for deer. California timber industry, like many states, stopped clear cutting a long time ago. When they did log, even in the 80's, they sprayed herbicides to kill all but the replanted trees, so feed sucks.

Bottom line, is I moved for a reason. If you are looking for a different experience, if you can get access to private ground, or just like the scenery, then I recommend it.

I do believe that the B zones and the Trinity wilderness may be one of the better areas, but again, not high populations, and not mule deer of course.

Great state for hogs, and at least 10 years ago, the ducks where great too. Lot's of good trout, bass, and even salmon fishing. I still cringe every time I think about the change from Fish and Game to Fish and Wildlife and with that kind of environment, I am glad I moved.
 
Understand, California has not allowed Mt Lions to be hunted for probably 40 years or more.

Prop 117 went into place in 1991, since that time the rate which mountain lions have been killed through depredation has gone up. In the one year true open season 1971-1972 the kills were 118. Then Ronald Reagan (yes that guy) signed a moratorium to end mountain lion hunting which was in place until 1986, there was then a 5 year hunting period until Prop 117 came into law.

I say this, because I think context is critically important. We still hunt lions, DFW kills more lions annually (on average) in the post Prop 117 world than when lion hunting was legal (outside of the bounty program). That said, with a state this size, and geographically diverse there are a host of variables at play.

Bounty Period 1907-1963 12,462
1971-72 Hunting Period 118
Depredation Kills 1964-1990 602
Depredation Kills 1991-2013 2,542
Bighorn Sheep Program 1999-2010 22
Public Safety Kills 1990-2013 144
Other / Unspecified 61
Total 15,951
 

Latest posts

Forum statistics

Threads
111,332
Messages
1,955,009
Members
35,128
Latest member
See65
Back
Top