Buy a new 357 Magnum (Which would you buy?)

If you are purchasing a new 357 Magnum to use, not for your collection, which would you buy?


  • Total voters
    41
  • Poll closed .
I just thought of something. I have a 44 magnum (2 now) but was wondering for those of you in bear country, would you feel it would do the job, or have any of you had experience with killing a bear with a 357 Magnum. I know it will kill other animals from a hunting standpoint and a defense standpoint.
Years ago, a Mt game warden was releasing a grizzly from a cylinder trap that was in the back of his truck. Upon release the bear turned around and shook the trap thus causing the warden to fall to the ground. The bear attacked and chewed his leg briefly while the warden fired 6 rounds into the head of the bear killing it. I believe they were 158 grain HP's. So it will work but there are better choices of calibers and bullet design.
 
So my main concern is that I might be in grizzly country hunting elk this fall. I already own an LCR .357 mag and a Super Redhawk 44 with a 9 1/2" barrel .Obviously I'm not going to carry that around with me. So that led me down the path of the GP100 in .357. I really like the idea of having 7 shots.
 
I prefer the buy once cry once approach. Verses having to take a S&W, Ruger, or whatever else to be tuned up. May as well start off perfect.
 

Attachments

  • IMG_7333.jpeg
    IMG_7333.jpeg
    3.8 MB · Views: 8
MY first centerfire pistol was a Ruger Balckhawk 6 1/2" .357 that I bought when I was still in the Army, stationed at Ft Sill, Oklahoma. I also bought a military model 1911 .45 while I was there, as I could draw and shoot a 50 round box of .45s every day at the range there. As an Intelligence Officer in Vietnam that was the only weapon that I was issued there (but I also carried a non-issued M-16). I carried one of those pistols for a number of years until I bought my first Ruger SBH .44 magnum.

I remember one time in the mid '70s, a friend and I were fishing on a creek in NW Montana. We were both carrying a pistol, and at our lunch break we shot some saucer size rocks. His .357 would break the rocks into several pieces while my .44 would turn the rocks into gravel.

25+ years ago I bought a 6" S&W Model 686. It's been years since I shot my Ruger .357, but I now shoot my S&W 686 every week with .38 Spl loads at steel.

About 5 years ago I bought a 4" S&W Model 626 .44 magnum. It has become my primary "in the Woods" carry pistol. I also shoot it every week at steel with .44 Spl loads.
 
So, I appreciate all the advice, support, and encouragement on getting the 357. After purchasing and shooting the Colt Kodiak (44 Magnum), I was leaning toward the Python.
I have held off and saved for months and found a great deal on a new one.

IMG_0778.jpeg

IMG_0781.jpeg

I may end up getting different grips.

Now one of you guys just need to purchase my very lightly used GP100
 
So, I appreciate all the advice, support, and encouragement on getting the 357. After purchasing and shooting the Colt Kodiak (44 Magnum), I was leaning toward the Python.
I have held off and saved for months and found a great deal on a new one.

View attachment 415053

View attachment 415054

I may end up getting different grips.

Now one of you guys just need to purchase my very lightly used GP100
Smart to go with the 4”! Sweet new pistol!
 
So, I appreciate all the advice, support, and encouragement on getting the 357. After purchasing and shooting the Colt Kodiak (44 Magnum), I was leaning toward the Python.
I have held off and saved for months and found a great deal on a new one.

View attachment 415053

View attachment 415054

I may end up getting different grips.

Now one of you guys just need to purchase my very lightly used GP100
I'll install the rubber grips for shooting,
 

Forum statistics

Threads
119,835
Messages
2,240,034
Members
39,020
Latest member
bblair
Back
Top