Best of times or worst of times for elk in eastern mt?

About time they do something about the ridiculous number of permits issued in the Breaks, especially archery permits. Hopefully it passes without issue, even though it’s at least 10 year too late.
The bio summed up the whole problem well:

“A lack of access fundamentally inhibits FWP’s ability to manage elk populations, and FWP continually tries to work with area landowners to improve hunter access and elk harvest,” she wrote. “Antlerless elk management is further complicated by bull management in this HD; HD 417 is a Special Management District (SMD) for bull elk per the 2023 (Elk Management Plan). The demand for limited-entry (LE) rifle and archery permits is high, and competition on public lands and for access to private lands among various hunters (either-sex elk, antlerless elk, deer, upland bird, etc.) further confounds elk management in this and other central MT elk HDs.”

Seperatelty the notion of people throwing a fit if they dont draw their preferred "le" archery district is a mystery to me. Im not happy about adding another august cow season but whatever i guess. Rich Bradley had choice words there - shout out to that guy

"Billings resident Rich Bradley was the only person to offer a comment on the proposal. He wrote in an email to the department that cow elk tags should be limited to private lands enrolled in the Block Management Program, which allow public access."
 
The bio summed up the whole problem well:

“A lack of access fundamentally inhibits FWP’s ability to manage elk populations, and FWP continually tries to work with area landowners to improve hunter access and elk harvest,” she wrote. “Antlerless elk management is further complicated by bull management in this HD; HD 417 is a Special Management District (SMD) for bull elk per the 2023 (Elk Management Plan). The demand for limited-entry (LE) rifle and archery permits is high, and competition on public lands and for access to private lands among various hunters (either-sex elk, antlerless elk, deer, upland bird, etc.) further confounds elk management in this and other central MT elk HDs.”

Seperatelty the notion of people throwing a fit if they dont draw their preferred "le" archery district is a mystery to me. Im not happy about adding another august cow season but whatever i guess. Rich Bradley had choice words there - shout out to that guy

"Billings resident Rich Bradley was the only person to offer a comment on the proposal. He wrote in an email to the department that cow elk tags should be limited to private lands enrolled in the Block Management Program, which allow public access."
How is that going to do anything but make those BMA's insufferable to hunt for everyone?
 
The hope is that it incentivizes more landowners to enroll in block management rather than outfit.
It may some smaller landowners, but isn't there 1 or 2 huge ranches that harbor the majority of the elk in that unit? I can't see them giving a shit about enrolling in Block Management unless the enrolled $$$ was pretty ridiculous.
 
About time they do something about the ridiculous number of permits issued in the Breaks, especially archery permits. Hopefully it passes without issue, even though it’s at least 10 year too late.
I agree with a tighter limit on the archery permits. Rifle permits also. The unit I hunted cows in offers more bull permits than for cows. And I think the management needs to be unit, not region specific. mtmuley
 
Billings resident Rich Bradley was the only person to offer a comment on the proposal. He wrote in an email to the department that cow elk tags should be limited to private lands enrolled in the Block Management Program, which allow public access. “The wealthy private land owners and outfitters are hoarding the public's elk,” he wrote.

Seriously? He was the ONLY person to comment?
 
It may some smaller landowners, but isn't there 1 or 2 huge ranches that harbor the majority of the elk in that unit? I can't see them giving a shit about enrolling in Block Management unless the enrolled $$$ was pretty ridiculous.
So why does the public land need to be piss pounded with hunters if that ranch has problems with its neighbors differences on elk tolerance?
 
So why does the public land need to be piss pounded with hunters if that ranch has problems with its neighbors differences on elk tolerance?
I do have sympathy for some of the landowners in 417. Others like to bitch and moan about too many elk while simultaneously charging for elk hunting. I have no sympathy for them.
 
Others like to bitch and moan about too many elk while simultaneously charging for elk hunting.
Theres a lot of financial incentive for that fairytale of a story. So much so that it sadly makes it hard for the general public to see the difference between people who have issues with elk crop reduction.

Perhaps even incentive enough to pay out of state lobbyists to tell another story and say we should regulate cow elk like deer.
 
I know! Just make it "unlimited" so as many nr clients can buy them on the open market.

Works great for bens employer by white sulphur.
The funny thing is 5 years ago when the commission tried to make the 799 tag general on private lands almost everyone commented that they should make cow tags limited to private lands, cause that's what makes more elk. Everyone agreed. Now, here we are.
 
So why does the public land need to be piss pounded with hunters if that ranch has problems with its neighbors differences on elk tolerance?

There is not supposed to be any additional public land hunting opportunity with the proposed 417 changes. The current proposal is essentially a “super-lite” version of Wargo’s private land antlerless only proposal. Right now, 417 has 50 B tags valid on all lands (public/private, HD-wide), and that’s the only option for cow harvest in the north end of the HD. 004/general are only valid in the south on private, BLM, and state and there’s currently a also late shoulder there. The only recourse for landowners in the north is finding one of those 50 cow tag holders who can hunt the whole HD. This proposal makes the 004/general valid only on private lands in the north part of the HD to provide a little more flexibility to those landowners specifically, without adding additional hunters on public. It will be up to them and on them (or at least the ones with elk issues) to use the change to help themselves.

The early shoulder is also proposed valid on private land only; some landowners have issues only around harvest time and if they want to help themselves, now they could. In a perfect world, this would shuffle elk around on to public right before archery.. alas this isn’t a perfect world and that’ll remain to be seen.

Also, related to the commenter in the news article, it’s not a fair request to make some options only for BMA landowners. BMA isn’t for everyone, and there are still landowners that allow ‘public’ (non-family, sometimes non-friends) hunting not in the BMA program. That’s still access even if it’s not for Joe Hunter.
 
Back
Top