I currently live in Noblesville on the NE side of Indy. I grew up in Gibson County, north of Evansville, but did most of my hunting in Pike County. Now I spend most of my hunting time in Crawford County. I own some land + cabin there with my brother in law, plus it's one of the few counties with a good amount of public ground.
I hear ya on the West ruining hunting here for you. My wife and I lived in UT for 9 years while I went to graduate school and then worked for the BLM. I used to get paid to do what I have to take vacation to do now... Good luck to you as well.