This is a curious issue because it looks like it groups well just in the wrong spot. When a scope failure has happened in the past it either won't shoot the same place twice or the reticle movement is wrong (won't move or track wrong 1 click might be 1/2" and 2 clicks might be 3") but that was with old Burris Fullfield II scopes.
I still think I'd go back to the starting point and work your way back. It will cost you expensive ammo. That way you have some talking points with Talley, Zeiss, and the base manufacturer. I would also call as you'll likely be able to troubleshoot in real time. What bases are you using?
I have never used the Talley vertical rings that require additional bases only the lightweight base/ring combo. I have them on 4 rifles and the only issue I've had was when MidwayUSA sent me an open package with mixed ring height and Talley replaced with no questions asked. Midway on the other hand couldn't have cared less. I lap all rings regardless of brand. It's part of my process for consistency.