Montana Mule Deer Mismanagement

Where I live mule deer doe harvest over the last decade+ has been essentially negligible on the grand scale. The biggest change here is the combination of moisture and relatively mild winters since 2023. Even the heavy snow we got in W24-25 was short-lived. The good conditions undoubtedly confound any changes made to season structure. Probably different than where there’s a lot more doe harvest obviously but I chalk a significant gain in mule deer numbers to better weather.
I think 2019 - Spring 2023 were the worst years weather wise for mule deer/pronghorn in my lifetime.
 
Where I live mule deer doe harvest over the last decade+ has been essentially negligible on the grand scale. The biggest change here is the combination of moisture and relatively mild winters since 2023. Even the heavy snow we got in W24-25 was short-lived. The good conditions undoubtedly confound any changes made to season structure. Probably different than where there’s a lot more doe harvest obviously but I chalk a significant gain in mule deer numbers to better weather.
Maybe specific to your area. I can definitely say there were more deer where I was last week, does especially, than in past years. mtmuley

I think both can be true. Region 7 definitely seems to show improvement in numbers of does on public land.
 
I think the years I referenced were worse because of the severity of the droughts. I'd take concurrent bad winters over concurrent bad droughts. And 2021-2022 was bad bad.
Not that it matters but deer and antelope numbers never came back from that 09-12 timeframe. Hopefully MTFWP has learned some lessons with doe tags since then.
 
Not that it matters but deer and antelope numbers never came back from that 09-12 timeframe. Hopefully MTFWP has learned some lessons with doe tags since then.
I mostly agree on that. There are some pockets I've found that I thought were getting close but overall I think you're right. Some areas in northern 7 saw like 80% or greater mortality in 11'.
 
  • Like
Reactions: DFS
I’ve already reached out to my local legislator about carrying a bill to make these handouts be full priced. I’d prefer to see them go away altogether. Getting rid of these or making these former residents pay the full NR price seems like a no brainer and a low hanging fruit. The vast majority of constituents would fully support it.
And what was your local legislator’s response?
 
One bright spot that is t really being talked about right now is that a couple years of eliminating mule deer doe harvest on public land seems to be having a positive effect .
Very much so. just the other day I noticed some does headed up into public with a fair buck in tow. Three years ago those does would avoid that public this time of year, because of all the bad experience from the first part of the season.
 
I think 2019 - Spring 2023 were the worst years weather wise for mule deer/pronghorn in my lifetime.
Worst winter 78/79 only 96/97 is close. 11/12 not to bad in comparison, but as far south as I am, we missed the worst of it.
Worst drought was 88, There was no green up that year. 21 and 22 might have been harder on the deer as it was two bad years in a row. But to be fair there wasn't many good years in the 80's when it came to moisture. Some where I saw where Broadus gained an inch on the 30 year average precipitation when the 80's timed out. The deer numbers are better on public this year for sure, but this year has been every bit as dry as 21 and 22 so we will have to wait and see about next year.
 
I think the years I referenced were worse because of the severity of the droughts. I'd take concurrent bad winters over concurrent bad droughts. And 2021-2022 was bad bad.
2021 drought was brutal. I don’t think we greened up at all that spring. We had pine trees the grasshoppers ate the needles off of because that’s the only thing around that was green This picture was July 4 of that year. That grass my daughter is standing on wasn’t mowed or grazed. It just never grew
IMG_9830.jpeg
 

Forum statistics

Threads
120,518
Messages
2,262,428
Members
39,138
Latest member
BPhelps
Back
Top