Hunting for food.

MTGomer

Well-known member
Joined
Sep 25, 2015
Messages
6,336
Location
MT —> AZ
I recently saw a discussion about raising resident tag prices. People were claiming that paying more than $20 for an elk tag would deprive the poor and downtrodden from acquiring protein for the table, because people are hunting to feed themselves and their families and are reliant on hunting for cheap protein.

I find this perspective to be quite surprising.

With the exception of some unique situations such as drawing a Moose tag and then having one walk across your front yard and killing it with an inherited rifle and then cutting it up at home, I do not believe there is hardly anybody coming out ahead financially on hunting.

I understand some people hunt for food, as in it is healthier, more moral, etc. I agree and it is one of the primary motivators for me to hunt. I just simply do not buy the financial argument.

Is there anybody on this page that resides in the L48 that believes that you are hunting due to finances and can show your work on how it pencils?
 
Wild game is the most expensive “free” protein I’ve ever had. If my calculations are correct, whitetail costs $200-300/pound, and I don’t even want to think about duck, goose or turkey.
 
I know a guy that hunts for food. He did not go out until this week since the deer are rutting hard trying to make it pencil out. He will probably not hunt a day for elk because he didn't draw the out the truck window cow tag that he wants. I think he has hunted 2 times for deer without success, and he has a doe whitetail tag. I am pretty sure he will end the season in the red. Laziness is a contributing factor.

I think sometimes I could end a season in the black if I killed the first elk I saw and then quit, but I would average out in the red over time. It is never going to happen.
 
I know plenty of people who do all their "hunting" on their own land and spend very little money doing it. If you factor in the cost of the land I suppose it wouldn't pencil out, but that doesn't make sense to me, land has it's own value. But I'd also argue that raising a resident tag cost wouldn't have much effect on cost per pound in dollars, not percent.

I guess it depends on how you look at the expenses. If I get a cow tag in my favorite state for 300, spend that much on fuel, sleep in my vehicle or camp, and get one on the first trip, 150lbs of meat for 600$ is $4/lb for elk meat, I'd say that's a good deal. I consider the gear a capital investment that I budget mostly under recreation. I don't spend a lot on gear compared to many. If it takes 2 or 3 trips out there with gas prices like they are now, it's not such a great price, but I get more out of it recreationally.

I'd imagine someone like @shrapnel could stack up enough food for a large family at very little cost if you don't factor in the price of guns, which in his case I'd put the guns under collector items/investments rather than hunting expenses.
 
If I get a cow tag in my favorite state for 300, spend that much on fuel, sleep in my vehicle or camp, and get one on the first trip, 150lbs of meat for 600$ is $4/lb for elk meat, I'd say that's a good deal.


I agree. Surprisingly what I’m talking about is over-the-counter bull tags that cost $20 and allow for five weeks of general archery, five weeks of general rifle, being raised to a hypothetical $100 making hunting a “ rich man sport“ as some commentators put it
 
I agree. Surprisingly what I’m talking about is over-the-counter bull tags that cost $20 and allow for five weeks of general archery, five weeks of general rifle, being raised to a hypothetical $100 making hunting a “ rich man sport“ as some commentators put it
If you're hunting bulls, the for food argument gets weak quick. Why spend extra fuel and time hunting antlers if you're looking to save cost.
 
If you're hunting bulls, the for food argument gets weak quick. Why spend extra fuel and time hunting antlers if you're looking to save cost.
In the areas that I hunt the odds of killing a regular season cow elk on public land is a fraction of the odds on any legal bull.
 
I think I’m probably coming out ahead this year, but that’s because a newborn and toddler at home made me focus on meat-producing hunts and skip the fun ones. I’m still cutting up my cow but I’m over 60lb grind with the two fronts left so at $6/lb for burger, I’m confident I’ve spent less on fuel and gear than the $500+ in burger I’ll have. But this is probably the only year I’m not in the red. The way I justify it is that none of my hobbies are cheap, but at least this one puts some good organic meat in the freezer and whatever else I’d be doing with all that time would probably cost even more.
 
I "hunt" our own property and my immediate neighboring properties. It definitely saves money. I usually get 2 decent bucks every year. A basic license and 1 deer tag is about 100 bucks and I think the second tag is about another 50. Not figuring the cost of rifles or ammo, land etc. I'm putting meat in the freezer at about 1-2 bucks a pound. If elk tags weren't so ridiculously priced I would put an elk that regularly walk through here in the freezer also.
 
I "hunt" our own property and my immediate neighboring properties. It definitely saves money. I usually get 2 decent bucks every year. A basic license and 1 deer tag is about 100 bucks and I think the second tag is about another 50. Not figuring the cost of rifles or ammo, land etc. I'm putting meat in the freezer at about 1-2 bucks a pound. If elk tags weren't so ridiculously priced I would put an elk that regularly walk through here in the freezer also.
Curious - what is "ridiculously" priced?

Id be willing to pay a lot more than i do in mt - especially if it meant an improvement in experience.
 
An elk tag in California costs $610.20 for residents and $1,871.80 for nonresidents.

Additional Costs & Rules

• Drawing application fee: $8.38 non-refundable fee per species (elk tags are issued through a draw).
Picture taken from my back yard .
PXL_20260902_134755790.jpg
 
Hey, guys, c’mon now. I just got back from a third season CO deer hunt. Round numbers:

Nonresident CO deer tag: $500
Gas roundtrip San Antonio to Gunnison: $350
Camp food: $100
Deer processing: $200
Two nights in hotel: $250
Meals on the road: $75
Total: $1475

For 65 lbs of rutting mule deer meat, I’m sitting at around $23/pound. Just feedin’ the family, fellas.
 

Forum statistics

Threads
120,539
Messages
2,263,160
Members
39,140
Latest member
kula270
Back
Top