First Bull, Colorado Muzzleloader

BEvans

Well-known member
Joined
Sep 21, 2022
Messages
91
Location
Colorado
I’ve been “hunting elk” since I was 12, though really it was just a bull tag after deer season or the occasional cow tag. Early years it was road hunting with my uncle. Later, my dad would join us and tell stories of way back when he was a kid and he and my grandpa would backpack into the wilderness after rutting bulls. He told me if I ever actually wanted an elk, that’s what it would take.

We never had much luck road hunting, and the only times I got close were the years I skipped buying a bull tag picked up a cow tag instead. Once I got to college, I started hunting OTC elk with classmates and quickly realized the elk were always miles into the roadless country. I told my father I planned on getting a tent and backpacking after them, and he was ecstatic. He convinced me muzzleloader during the rut was the way to go, and to let him take me to one of the spots where he and my grandfather used to go. It wasn’t his wilderness area, but a good place to start. He dusted off my grandfather’s old Knight muzzleloaders and spent the summer getting me dialed in. The following September we parked at the trailhead and started hiking up the mountain my father remembered as a child. Shortly after hiking in we started hearing bugles. We never saw a bull but I passed on a few cows as I was always hearing bugles only a few hundred yards away. The following year my dad drew the same tag and had a similar experience but laid eyes on a few bulls that he never got a shot opportunity for. On both trips we only hunted the weekends as I was in school and professors wouldn’t give me the time off to hunt.

This year, first season after graduating, I have the same tag and I could finally take the full season to find a bull.


Day 1 (Saturday)
After driving all night, I napped in the truck bed at the trailhead. My dad was bringing the RV later. At 7 a.m., hiking solo, I heard weak bugles from the valley below. I didn’t believe they were elk. Assuming they were midwesterners who picked up a bugle tube as a last minute thought, I kept hiking.

A couple hours later, I spotted cows and a 5 point bull. I cow called, and the bull bugled back before catching up to his cows. Then out of nowhere, a cow popped up at 20 yards and stared me down. I mewed softly and apparently she doesn’t discriminate based on looks because she continued to casually walk by… At least until she finally winded me and ran off.

1758666905601.png
One of the first elk I had seen on this trip. I can’t remember if this was the 5 point or a cow.


1758666905789.png
A horrible picture of the cow at 20 yards, you can see her eye just above the thick branch in the center.


At this point, I had only practiced bugling in my car and wasn’t confident enough to talk to a real bull. I began to hike down the mountain expecting my father to arrive shortly. The whole way down I continued to hear the pathetic bugles I first heard in the morning, although to my surprise, there were no other trucks parked at the trail head. I finally accepted that the bugles were real and if they could sound that bad, then my bugling couldn’t be any worse. I get ahold of my father and find out he was still several hours out so I headed back up the mountain.

That afternoon, storms rolled in. Fog, wind, misting rain. Near the meadow, I cow called and two bulls answered. I finally decided to bugle, and to my surprise instead of dead silence or the sound of elk running off, I got responses. One gave a lazy bugle and the other ripped an aggressive, raspy challenge. For half an hour we traded “F-yous” back and forth.

Shivering in my soaked polyester clothes, I watched a cow spawn out of the fog, once again at 20 yards. As she got past, she winded me and began running back toward the bulls. After the previous experience with a cow that close, I cow called to her. She slowed down looking back at me. I then gave her a gentle bugle which stopped her. She then looked away and slowly walked back to the herd without spooking them. Minutes later, a dark shape emerged. A 5-point at 50 yards, hidden behind a tree. As I steadied, another shape appeared through a break in the fog. A heavy 6-point with dark antlers and ivory tips gleaming, and screaming every few steps as he closed to 70 yards.1758666905846.png

The cow at 20 yards through the fog




1758666905900.png

The 5 point through the fog, behind the tree



I was shaking so badly I couldn’t steady for a shot, and the thought of freezing for hours after a kill made me hesitate. The 6-point searched for me, bugling hard, but I went silent and let them drift away. By the time I hit the truck, I was soaked and numb, but ecstatic. It was the best day of hunting I’d ever had, even without pulling the trigger.1758666905962.png

The 6 point bull during a break in the fog, waiting for my chance to escape undetected.
 

Attachments

  • 1758666907448.png
    1758666907448.png
    1.5 MB · Views: 38
Day 2 (Sunday)

I hiked in at shooting light while my dad had coffee in camp. The weather turned again. Fog and mist with bulls bugling below. At the meadow, I bugled and immediately got cut off by a pissed off bull. Deep, raspy, and chuckles at the end. Through the fog, I could barely make out what I believe to be the same 6 point from the night before

I moved to close the distance and kept bugling with an occasional cow call, but the new angle blocked my view. When I finally peeked out, he was staring at me just out of range. I eased back into cover, but minutes later he bugled further away. He didn’t spook, just didn’t like what he saw.

Later, my dad’s Ranger broke down, so I hiked out and spent the afternoon fixing it, which ended hunting for the day early. Still, I’d had another close encounter and my optimism was through the roof and considering passing on a 5 point if given the opportunity for a chance to tag the 6 point.


Day 3 (Monday)
Clear skies, steady wind, and dead silence. No bugles all morning. I sat the meadow for hours waiting for my dad to finish his coffee and catch up. The rest of the day we hiked game trails that dropped into the dark timber to let off a bugle and see if we could get a response. Dead silence all day, except for the wind, which may have partially been the reason we didn’t even hear distant bugles.

That evening I glassed a bull pushing cows in a meadow far below, but didn’t drop 1,000 feet in elevation to go after him. Hiking out, I glassed more cows below cliffs, just off the main trail. No more bulls. A stark contrast to the adrenaline of the first two days, I told myself the next bull I saw in range, I’d shoot.1758668409333.pngElk in meadow down below




Day 4 (Tuesday)

I woke up at 5 a.m. freezing in my sleeping bag. propane tank ran out and RV had no heat. In nothing but underwear, I swapped bottles in an ice/rain storm, got pelted with hail, then crawled back into my bag traumatized and shivering until 9 a.m.

When I finally hiked in, at the meadow, bugling erupted below. I thought he’d climb into the meadow, but instead another bull answered and the two angled toward each other. Soon cows filtered by the bottom edge of the meadow as bulls were screaming at each other.
I decided to get in on the action and dropped into the timber. I bugled and had four bulls respond from across the valley. One came close enough I could hear every footstep, every breath, and every stick snap as he paced back and forth responding to my aggressive bugles. He eventually started working away from me while still bugling. I decided to head back to meet my father.

While I climbed back toward the meadow, I heard 3 mews and looked up. Above me was four cows at 40 yards, directly in my thermal. They took off and suddenly 20+ cows, a 5 point, and two 6-points thundered out of the top of the meadow. If I’d just sat tight instead of chasing the bugles, they would have come right into my setup with perfect wind. My dad, who’d climbed to my spot while I was gone, watched it all unfold helplessly from above.1758668409443.pngThe only bull of the group I managed to get on camera.


1758668409527.pngAll these images are just screenshots from videos, the videos look better.
Later, a lone cow chirped at the top of the meadow. I chirped back and she dropped to 40 yards before winding us and trotting off. My father hiked off the mountain as a storm was moving in. He decided to head home, only planning to come back if I shot something. I planned on staying in my tent a mile from where I was finding the elk. Just before dark, the storm cleared and I got my first real sunset in days.

1758668409639.pngCow skylined


1758668409760.pngSunset from tent
 
I’ve been “hunting elk” since I was 12, though really it was just a bull tag after deer season or the occasional cow tag. Early years it was road hunting with my uncle. Later, my dad would join us and tell stories of way back when he was a kid and he and my grandpa would backpack into the wilderness after rutting bulls. He told me if I ever actually wanted an elk, that’s what it would take.

We never had much luck road hunting, and the only times I got close were the years I skipped buying a bull tag picked up a cow tag instead. Once I got to college, I started hunting OTC elk with classmates and quickly realized the elk were always miles into the roadless country. I told my father I planned on getting a tent and backpacking after them, and he was ecstatic. He convinced me muzzleloader during the rut was the way to go, and to let him take me to one of the spots where he and my grandfather used to go. It wasn’t his wilderness area, but a good place to start. He dusted off my grandfather’s old Knight muzzleloaders and spent the summer getting me dialed in. The following September we parked at the trailhead and started hiking up the mountain my father remembered as a child. Shortly after hiking in we started hearing bugles. We never saw a bull but I passed on a few cows as I was always hearing bugles only a few hundred yards away. The following year my dad drew the same tag and had a similar experience but laid eyes on a few bulls that he never got a shot opportunity for. On both trips we only hunted the weekends as I was in school and professors wouldn’t give me the time off to hunt.

This year, first season after graduating, I have the same tag and I could finally take the full season to find a bull.


Day 1 (Saturday)
After driving all night, I napped in the truck bed at the trailhead. My dad was bringing the RV later. At 7 a.m., hiking solo, I heard weak bugles from the valley below. I didn’t believe they were elk. Assuming they were midwesterners who picked up a bugle tube as a last minute thought, I kept hiking.

A couple hours later, I spotted cows and a 5 point bull. I cow called, and the bull bugled back before catching up to his cows. Then out of nowhere, a cow popped up at 20 yards and stared me down. I mewed softly and apparently she doesn’t discriminate based on looks because she continued to casually walk by… At least until she finally winded me and ran off.

View attachment 386850
One of the first elk I had seen on this trip. I can’t remember if this was the 5 point or a cow.


View attachment 386854
A horrible picture of the cow at 20 yards, you can see her eye just above the thick branch in the center.


At this point, I had only practiced bugling in my car and wasn’t confident enough to talk to a real bull. I began to hike down the mountain expecting my father to arrive shortly. The whole way down I continued to hear the pathetic bugles I first heard in the morning, although to my surprise, there were no other trucks parked at the trail head. I finally accepted that the bugles were real and if they could sound that bad, then my bugling couldn’t be any worse. I get ahold of my father and find out he was still several hours out so I headed back up the mountain.

That afternoon, storms rolled in. Fog, wind, misting rain. Near the meadow, I cow called and two bulls answered. I finally decided to bugle, and to my surprise instead of dead silence or the sound of elk running off, I got responses. One gave a lazy bugle and the other ripped an aggressive, raspy challenge. For half an hour we traded “F-yous” back and forth.

Shivering in my soaked polyester clothes, I watched a cow spawn out of the fog, once again at 20 yards. As she got past, she winded me and began running back toward the bulls. After the previous experience with a cow that close, I cow called to her. She slowed down looking back at me. I then gave her a gentle bugle which stopped her. She then looked away and slowly walked back to the herd without spooking them. Minutes later, a dark shape emerged. A 5-point at 50 yards, hidden behind a tree. As I steadied, another shape appeared through a break in the fog. A heavy 6-point with dark antlers and ivory tips gleaming, and screaming every few steps as he closed to 70 yards.View attachment 386852

The cow at 20 yards through the fog




View attachment 386851

The 5 point through the fog, behind the tree



I was shaking so badly I couldn’t steady for a shot, and the thought of freezing for hours after a kill made me hesitate. The 6-point searched for me, bugling hard, but I went silent and let them drift away. By the time I hit the truck, I was soaked and numb, but ecstatic. It was the best day of hunting I’d ever had, even without pulling the trigger.View attachment 386853

The 6 point bull during a break in the fog, waiting for my chance to escape undetected.
Great story for your first day! That last picture looks like a perfect opportunity for a shot. Were you loaded and cocked? That may be your first and last opportunity on this trip. Instead of shooting with your camera, next time shoot with your muzzleloader. Opportunities like that don't happen all that often. Keep us posted!! Good luck!
 
Day 5 (Wednesday)
I woke up damp but not cold, cooked breakfast, and heard bugles faintly in the distance. At first light I glassed a cow and two spikes 50 yards from my tent, below a cliff. I hiked to the meadow and I settled in for an all day sit, determined to not miss a big herd moving through again.

1758669109670.pngElk in meadow below tent.
I sat all day, soaking in sunshine and steady bugles. Mid morning I debated drying wet clothes but didn’t want to risk an elk spotting me moving around. Finally, as bugling slowed, I strung them out in the sun and slipped back without issue.

By 4 p.m. a single bull was bugling his head off, at least once every 5 minutes but more often twice in 5 minutes, but no other bull ever responded. So much bugling I would have thought it was a hunter, but it sounded like the bull I had chased in the timber. He didn’t sound super far off, but I wanted to spend the day being silent so I never responded. Clouds thickened and sprinkled rain. At dark, I heard a couple more faint bugles but saw no elk. Spent another quiet night in the tent.



Day 6 (Thursday)

I overslept and didn’t start until 7 a.m. Spotted elk close to the trailhead which made me question if I really needed to be so far back. Still, I pushed up to the meadow.1758669109811.pngElk closer to the trailhead

The same bull that was bugling his head off the night before, which was also the bull I chased in the timber, was still bugling like crazy. I initially tried to still stay silent, but after a couple hours of listening to him bugle I couldn’t take it any more. I bugled back and he immediately responded with a challenge bugle. I played with him for a while, bugling back and forth occasionally mixing in a cow call. Eventually he walked out of the timber to the edge of the meadow down below looking for me. He was a decent 5 point or a small 6. He was at 270 yards and wouldn’t come any closer but was still bugling. Eventually he walked back into the timber and continued bugling. I decided I had enough sitting around waiting for the elk to come to me and went after him.
1758669109923.pngBull came out of the timber to investigate my calling

He was smaller than the big herd bulls I’ve been seeing, and being so active while everyone else was quiet, I assumed he was a satellite bull that's been desperate for a cow but getting his butt kicked, and that's why he wasn’t coming into my bugles from the several previous days.

I hiked across the meadow and got set up 60 yards from where he peaked through the timber into the meadow. My plan was to stick to cow calls hoping to entice the desperate satellite bull. Every time I called he would respond with a bugle. I could hear him once again pacing back and forth, breathing, and breaking sticks. It didn’t take long for me to lose patience and let out a bugle. He responded but then immediately worked away from where I was at. I decided to back out.

After a week in the woods, I decided to head out early to run to town and get my first shower in almost a week. On my way out, in between my tent and the trail head, I kicked a rock that rolled off a cliff and spooked two different herds. I only saw bodies but there were enough of them I assume there was a bull or two. The trail I had been using was also full of elk tracks. Once again, I wondered if I was hunting deeper than I needed to.

That night I drove to town and found a place with showers and a laundromat. After cleaning up I went to a bar for a burger and a beer to mentally reset for the last few days.
 
Day 7 (Friday)

Slept in the truck. At dawn I woke to sniffing at the tailgate — heart pounding, thinking of a hunter’s story about a bear pawing and sniffing his tent. With my pistol in the cab, I primed the muzzleloader, peeked out… and saw a cow licking my truck. A dozen cattle scattered when I opened the tailgate. Two seconds of rational thoughts could've saved me the adrenaline rush of thinking a bear was breaking in. But hey, at least I was awake now.

Up the mountain, I heard the familiar accent of the bull I’d been chasing the previous days. I decided to once again ease in using very little calling, cow calls only, still thinking he's a satellite bull. He was bugling without me having to call to him. I would only cow call occasionally as I slipped through the forest, hoping if he heard me coming he would be expecting a cow. As I get closer his bugles are vibrating through my chest. I can hear sticks breaking all around me. The furthest I could see is 40 yards. Eventually I spot an elk at 40 yards staring at me. I can see its head and vitals but can't see above its eyes. I wait for a few minutes waiting for it to move to confirm it’s the bull before I shoot. I let off a cow call and it went back to grazing. It was just a cow. Before long, I realized I was inside his herd. Cows fed around me, some stared, some grazed. In hindsight, I feel like this is when I should have bugled. Being surrounded by his cows, I assume he would be forced to come defend his harem. I guess he was not a satellite bull. I instead continue trying to close in to the bugles and a cow decides she has had enough. She takes off and the whole mountain explodes. Cows all around vanish just as fast as they appeared.

The bull is of course silent now and probably on the next mountain over, but there is another bull he was bugling to, and that bull continues to bugle. One of the strangest bugles I've ever heard. I could hear the start and the end with chuckles, but there was no high note in the bugle. I start to slowly work toward this bull and catch a glimpse of elk silently moving through the woods. I sit down, still only occasionally cow calling. Next thing I know, I have a cow standing next to me at 7 yards. I cow call to her and she starts feeding. Every time I move she stops to stare, but doesn’t spook.
1758670966656.png
Cow hanging out with me while I call.

I then spot another elk slowly walking towards me. A young bull. 5×5, smaller than the bulls I’d seen, but feeding calmly toward me. He paused at 40, then 30, then at 20 yards turned broadside.
1758671010207.png
Bull feeding towards me.

I debated passing, but it was Friday, my pronghorn tag opened Sunday, and the opportunity was too perfect not to take. I raised, squeezed, and smoke filled the air. It cleared just in time to see both the cow that had been beside me and the bull disappear into the dense timber. I heard branches breaking for a few seconds, and then everything went silent. I expected the elk to run, but I wasn’t used to this every deer I’d killed before had dropped in its tracks.

I checked the time: 11:30. Before the hunt, I’d promised myself I would wait 30 minutes after a shot before tracking, just in case it wasn’t perfect. That way I wouldn’t bump the bull and push him all over the mountain. So I reloaded, pulled out my lunch, and decided to eat while the clock ran down.

My mind was racing. For the half second I saw the bull after the smoke cleared, he didn’t look hurt. I’d heard him breaking sticks but never the crashing sound of him going down. Did I miss? How could I miss? The shot was the easiest I’ve ever had. Was it too perfect? Did I not even bother aiming because it was so close? The gun was sighted at 100 yards, and this shot was 20, steep downhill. Could that difference have thrown me off?

All of this churned in my head as adrenaline pumped and my spoon shook so badly I spilled corn everywhere. When I finally looked down, it was only 11:35. Five minutes? That's it??

By 11:55 I couldn’t take it anymore. Close enough. I marked my shooting position on OnX and eased toward where I thought the bull had stood. The smoke had robbed me of a clear reference, and I regretted waiting so long. If I’d started immediately, I’d at least have known where he was going.

I searched the ground for blood but found nothing. Fifty yards down, still nothing. Tracks crisscrossed everywhere, none of them obviously him. My stomach turned. I circled back, started over from the shot site, and tried again.

This time, at about 30 yards, I spotted a single drop of blood on the base of an aspen. Then a spatter in the dirt. Two steps later, more on a plant. A few steps after that, a log streaked red. I looked ahead, following the line of blood with my eyes and froze.

There, fifty yards downhill, was what looked like a tan rock. I raised my binos. Not a rock. My bull.
1758671051752.png
First look at the elk down.

I took a quick video to mark the spot and the route I’d take, afraid that once I stepped forward I’d lose sight and not find him again. It wasn’t a problem as a few minutes later I was standing over my bull. OnX showed he’d gone 98 yards. The shot was good, double lungs, just a little high with no pass-through. In hindsight, buck fever had made me panic way more than necessary. Next time, I’ll remind myself to aim for the lower lungs for hopefully a better blood trail.
1758671090294.png
I texted my dad, who immediately started the seven-hour drive back to camp. Then I set to work breaking the bull down, quickly realizing this wasn’t a deer I could roll around for the perfect angle. Every move took effort, and it was hours before I had him quartered and the skull skinned.

By 3 p.m., I loaded a hind quarter and the skull into my pack. It was the heaviest load I’d ever carried. Instead of following the easier track I’d taken in, I foolishly went straight uphill. The bull had only run 100 yards, but he dropped 200 feet of elevation. Fighting through deadfall and steep ground, it took an hour just to climb back to where I pulled the trigger.

From there it was still 1,000 yards and 400 feet of elevation gain to the meadow, before the trail finally sloped downhill. I reached the top around 6 p.m., drained. The downhill was faster, but still brutal every step weighed down by knowing I’d have to repeat it multiple times. The only comfort was knowing this would be my heaviest pack. Future trips wouldn’t include my gun or full gear.

I reached my tent just before sunset and got a text from my dad saying he’d arrived. I decided to push all the way down to the RV that night for heat and a real bed. By the time I staggered into the trailhead, it was 9 p.m., nine and a half hours after I pulled the trigger.

I collapsed into camp exhausted, determined that the rest of the meat would be boned out before packing it off the mountain.

The next day I boned out the remaining quarters. I packed up the two fonts, loins, and backstraps and brought them to the meadow for my father to take. He packed two bags at once to bring off the mountain and carried the third bag to my tent camp which was a lifesaver. With his help, I only had to make one more trip for the final hind quarter and then another only going as far as my tent for the remaining.

On Sunday morning, as I packed the final load, I heard a faint bugle in the distance… the first I heard since pulling the trigger. I felt satisfied I made the right choice shooting this bull instead of holding out as I likely would not have had another opportunity.

I would love to hear some advice as to what you would have done differently at any point of this hunt. A lot of this hunt was guessing what the next move should be or what call to make and would like to be better prepared next time. Thanks!
 
Last edited:
Great story for your first day! That last picture looks like a perfect opportunity for a shot. Were you loaded and cocked? That may be your first and last opportunity on this trip. Instead of shooting with your camera, next time shoot with your muzzleloader. Opportunities like that don't happen all that often. Keep us posted!! Good luck!
At one point I was lined up for the shot but I was shaking too much from the cold and adrenaline. I didn't feel comfortable taking a shot I wasn't 100% confident about.
 
I love it! Congratulations. I hope to chase elk again next season, but this time it will be DIY like your hunt
 
Now that’s a hunt!!! Congrats big time. As I was reading this, I thought how it’d be nice for guys to chime in with a critique of your hunt decisions. Not criticisms, but actual advice from those who’ve been there done that so to speak. And then you said similar in one of your last posts. Might be a good way for others to learn. Congrats again on a great hunt, a great experience, and a great bull.
 

Forum statistics

Threads
117,423
Messages
2,156,479
Members
38,215
Latest member
Richburgers
Back
Top