Buy a new 44 Magnum (Which would you buy?)

[Ben Lamb]

Fyi, some of the newer S&Ws don't have the lock.

S&W springs are easy to change and can make quite a bit lighter DA trigger. There are lots of videos on YouTube that cover about every model.

I've used the wolff spring kits on my S&W and on a Charter Arms Bulldog. Really easy to install and they make the trigger as good as my N-frame 357 that got it's trigger through round count.

 

[Wind Gypsy]

The 4” even works for hunting!

View attachment 404253

Those shades

 

[Dan O]

I owned a Colt Python years ago. The Python is a 357 mag and had a 6 inch barrel. It was a very nice firearm and I used it for duty carry in the beginning of my career. I have never shot the 44 mag Colt. I sold the python and went to a 4 inch Model 57 S&W 41 mag for duty carry. The S&W fit me much better. Since then I acquired a nickel S&W model 29 6 inch barrel. It fits me the same as the Model 57 both are N frames. The Model 29 & 629 have went through changes through the years. The new 29/629 are built to handle heavy loads much better than the older models. The new model 629 mountain guns do not have the lock and the barrel has a lighter contour. Go to the S&W website and check out the weight difference between the different models. For carry in the hills and possibly hunting a good balance IMHO is the 629 Classic with the 5 inch barrel. The full lug gives added weight that will help tame the recoil better than the 4 inch standard or mountain guns. Currently I own SBH 4 5/8 inch, SBH Hunter 7 1/2 barrel with 2x scope, SRH 7 1/2 inch and the S&W 29 6inch. Still have the 4 inch Model 57 nickel. I can use either the 29 or 57 in my chest holster barrel length doesn't matter.

If weight is a big deal go with the mountain gun. If not I would go with the S&W 629 classic 5 inch model. Still easy to carry but more comfortable to shoot. If you prefer single action check out the SBH 5 1/2 possibly in a Bisley grip. Whatever you chose enjoy it.

 

[noharleyyet]

J-38 snubbie, Triple 4" K-357's, L-357 snubbie 686 Plus 7 shot....40 Sig229 45 Kimber Super Carry Pro in the back ground

https://flic.kr/p/2s34B4o

 

[mtmuley]

Everyone seems to have a Smith. Colt, not so much. I looked into that Kodiak a bit. It's where I would go. mtmuley

 

[noharleyyet]

Everyone seems to have a Smith. Colt, not so much. I looked into that Kodiak a bit. It's where I would go. mtmuley

I'd have to sell the Smiths and add significant cash to have the Python I wanted Dale...

 

[mtmuley]

I'd have to sell the Smiths and add significant cash to have the Python I wanted Dale...

Yep. Those originals are really out of hand. Beautiful handguns. If only I would have paid attention 30 years ago. mtmuley

 

[Dan O]

Yep. Those originals are really out of hand. Beautiful handguns. If only I would have paid attention 30 years ago. mtmuley

I bought mine from a buddy in 1975 cost $150.00. It was like new.

 

[BAKPAKR]

Those shades

Those were my regular glasses! Photogray.

 

[Jbotto]

I think I could be very happy with a 4” S&W. A lot of the 629s feel a bit chunky to me, the Model 69 is pretty nice but I don’t want a 5-shot.

 

[WNC2500]

I bought mine from a buddy in 1975 cost $150.00. It was like new.

That’s crazy!!

 

[Nick87]

Are you selling the redhawk?

 

[WNC2500]

@Nick87 Nick, no sir. I’ll probably keep it forever.


I am thinking of selling the GP100 that is 6 inch barrel. (357) I bet I haven’t shot it 15 times

 

[elkduds]

The smaller the wheelgun frame, the more I carry it. Carry and hunting call for different construction/weight/barrel length IME. K frame size is my preference in 357. I had a large frame 44 mag off brand, DA, 7", it was like toting a boat anchor but easier to shoot accurately. Never hunted big game with a handgun. Say hello to my little titanium friend.

 

[BAKPAKR]

@Nick87 Nick, no sir. I’ll probably keep it forever.

View attachment 404295
I am thinking of selling the GP100 that is 6 inch barrel. (357) I bet I haven’t shot it 15 times

View attachment 404294

I forgot that your brother makes some good looking holsters.

 

[WNC2500]

I forgot that your brother makes some good looking holsters.

@BAKPAKR It is insane, he makes custom ones, and every new gun I buy, I let him have the gun (if he doesn't have a "blue gun" mold already) and tell him to surprise me. Always impressive stuff.

If anyone wants to check him out, he is burdettegunleather on IG.

 

[338win]

I carried a 4 inch red hawk 44 for years but it was a heavy piece. Ended up carrying a SP101 in 357 with hard casts for a nearly a decade. I’d go with the lightest one available that can handle the ammo you like

 

[Blue Steel]

I’ve had a few later model 629s and Super Blackhawks. Recently looked at a used Bisley Super BH that was some limited edition. Very nice, tough as Rugers always are, and trigger good but not a Smith.

I’d vote for a Freedom Arms.

 

[BAKPAKR]

You could look for a 329 Nightguard if you are mainly thinking self defense. On the other hand, if self defense were the goal, I would just get a Glock 10mm.

 

[WNC2500]

I’ve had a few later model 629s and Super Blackhawks. Recently looked at a used Bisley Super BH that was some limited edition. Very nice, tough as Rugers always are, and trigger good but not a Smith.

I’d vote for a Freedom Arms.

Amen, @Blue Steel , I'd go for the Nate Romanowski version. That is past my price range. I can swing the Colt or S&W, but the Freedom Arms and the Korth get into used car price range.