Best of times or worst of times for elk in eastern mt?

@Eric Albus whats the moga solution? See youre in here liking stuff. We all know you and pashke are big friends to the resident hunter.

Curious - might as well here it from you rather than some lobbyist liar moga hired. Or a fake 501c3 group with a lobbyist that doesnt even have the ethics to register.
 
I can see where the August shoulder season could change the economics for some ranchers. My neighbor has had as many as 400 elk on his hayfields starting in late July. The crop loss to the second cutting is extensive, there no longer is a third cutting and the fall grazing for his cattle is all but gone. I am going to bet that his losses to elk are easily triple what his hunting lease pays. At face value, you would think that he would be all in on letting the public shoot elk to alleviate the losses. It is just not that simple. The current season is just too late in the year to make hunting a viable option to deal with crop loss. By the time the season starts the damage is done. One of the reasons landowners lease is to offset the losses to crops. If he can start shooting elk in August, hunting is now a viable way to deal with the elk. Will he kill enough elk to reduce the population, not a chance, but when elk are getting shot at with rifles they tend to leave for some place safer.
 
I can see where the August shoulder season could change the economics for some ranchers. My neighbor has had as many as 400 elk on his hayfields starting in late July. The crop loss to the second cutting is extensive, there no longer is a third cutting and the fall grazing for his cattle is all but gone. I am going to bet that his losses to elk are easily triple what his hunting lease pays. At face value, you would think that he would be all in on letting the public shoot elk to alleviate the losses. It is just not that simple. The current season is just too late in the year to make hunting a viable option to deal with crop loss. By the time the season starts the damage is done. One of the reasons landowners lease is to offset the losses to crops. If he can start shooting elk in August, hunting is now a viable way to deal with the elk. Will he kill enough elk to reduce the population, not a chance, but when elk are getting shot at with rifles they tend to leave for some place safer.
Would be suprised at all if anything that wasnt irrigated got a 3rd cutting in that part of MT this year - in fact id think that would be pretty unique most years. Does he typically?
 
Doesn’t that “someplace safer” guy eventually complain too?
I have always seen this as more of a landowner versus landowner issue rather than LO vs public land hunter.
That would depend on the owner of the someplace safer. If the owner is also counting on a hay crop, they are going to complain. I don't feel one bit sorry for them if they don't let people shoot them. If the owner is a out of state billionaire that bought they place for the elk hunting, they are not going complain about more elk. The risk to them is if they have to pasture all of the elk, starting in August, the elk will likely have their fields stripped clean and move on by the time hunting season starts.
 
  • Like
Reactions: DFS
I think there could be a lot of benefit to eliminating nonresident landowner tags. I really do not see a downside to it. No reason to incentivize a lot of the elk “problems” in Montana.
 
it’s also like watching a slow motion train wreck in several other hunting districts in Montana that are headed for the exact same place.
 
Back
Top