smarandr
Well-known member
Sometimes I'm amazed they even let us use compound bows and scopes on rifles here in Idaho.
Fixed Blade or Mechanical
- Thread starter Hawkeye
- Start date
Sometimes I'm amazed they even let us use compound bows and scopes on rifles here in Idaho.
JohnCushman
Well-known member
I wish they would do that here in Colorado too.
Goldtip
New member
- Joined
- Jul 29, 2009
- Messages
- 1,142
I've never shot mechanicals, always shot fixed. Started with Bear razorheads, went to Thunderheads, and 4 years ago switched to Sonics as they are a replaceable blade COC broadhead and wanted to try them. With proper bow tuning all have flown well and killed animals for me, and so I see no reason to change. No two ways about it, Mechanicals have a higher risk of failure to perform properly than a fixed blade broadhead. Yes, I am quite aware that many, many people have excellent results with mechanical heads. But I have excellent results with fixed, so why add one more potential problem to the equation. Just my 2cents.
174in
Well-known member
If I was forced to shoot a fixed blade I would start off with the shuttle t lock to try I have heard nothing but good.I have shot thunderheads,montecs, old style muzzy not the mx's,bear,and magnus stingers.Out of them the thunderheads and magnus would be the only ones I would rely on. Montecs came to dull and hard to sharpen the blood trails I got from them where next to nothing. The bears were to hard to find.And the muzzy's blades seemed weak like the were made out of aluminum or something.
HUNTMAN
Active member
I like slick tricks. They fly like darts and tune as easy as any broadhead on the market. I have shot both fixed and mech. Both kill . But fixed blades are ALWAYS cutting.
174in
Well-known member
Do the slick tricks come pretty sharp? I heard the are a good head also. Any one tried the blood runner by NAP? Been thinking about trying some but I just cant get myself to do it since I have had such good luck with the reapers the last 5 or 6 years.They deer just dont seem to go far when hit with that head for some reason and there is ussually alot of blood on the ground.
Gunner46
Well-known member
Old School here. 100 gr. ThunderHeads.....Sharpened to the edge of a razor. No reason to Mess With Success.
JohnCushman
Well-known member
Slick Tricks are scary sharp out of the package...I sliced a couple fingers when I got the first pack taking them out and putting them together...lol
Lone Star Outdoors Show
New member
- Joined
- Jan 13, 2012
- Messages
- 62
Shot this South Texas buck with Slick Tricks last weekend. The arrow did not pass thru as the shot placement wasn't perfect. But the blood trail was solid and he went down for good within a half hour. Love em!
Removed from the buck
Fatrack
Well-known member
i got turned to mechanicals a few years ago and since then I've been shooting the rage exclusively. I've killed elk, deer, antelope and a moose all with the rage. BUT....I've also lost my two best animals, one being an elk and one being a mule deer, with the rage on shots that "should" have killed. So....what to do?
d-bone20917
Member
I have never used a mechanical BH. I used Thunderheads for years but recently switched to hunting with a recurve only and have been using the VPA Terminators. However, this year I'm thing about giving the Muzzy Phantom 2 blades a try. Hopefully I'l get to see how they work during turkey season in May.
A 270 gr arrow from a #53 bow and a mechanical? You got lucky my friend. Not a set up appropriate for big game IMO.
I'm mostly a fixed blade guy too, but I can see some limited reasons to use a mechanical too. Shot placement is key with them. Hit shoulder and you may be in trouble.
I shoot the VPA 3 blades. Fly like a dart and there is not a tougher head made. Proven 3 blade cut on contact design that is precision machined from a solid block of steel. Not welded together with weak spots or made of cheap cast metal like it's competitors.
I shoot the VPA 3 blades. Fly like a dart and there is not a tougher head made. Proven 3 blade cut on contact design that is precision machined from a solid block of steel. Not welded together with weak spots or made of cheap cast metal like it's competitors.
WI avidhunter
New member
I shoot rage and have been happy with them, but I have never used anything else. I've talked to friends who are serious bow-hunters that have used others that prefer Rage too.
AZ Ron
Member
I've been shooting slick tricks, but may look at either the swhacker or ulmer edge broadheads for future use on deer, javelina, and turkey.
Ron
Ron
Classic35
Member
I guess I am old school - A fixed blade guy must be a hold over from my traditional days.
SWMontana1
New member
- Joined
- Sep 21, 2011
- Messages
- 337
Anyone use Montec?
Simple proven design, but made of cast metal. Check out the VPA line. Same design, better construction with solid machined steel. Much easier to sharpen too.
174in
Well-known member
No luck invovled been doing it for years without a problem its proven deadly everytime.3 of the animals have been 40yds+ with passthroughs.It all goes back to good shot placement and a well tuned bow.Belive me more deer are wounded every year from hunters that are pulling to much weight and not enough practice than someone shooting a light arrow or mechanical head.
MTbowhunter84
Member
I'm a fixed blade shooter. Have tried mechanical, just like the fixed better. Had very good luck with Muzzy Phantoms, but have recently went to MX3s. Also have shot spitfires in the past, just didn't like to change the blades as often as it was required. All I have ever shot were 100 gr.
