BigFin - Is the CPW using Onyourownadventures as a endorser? Just wondering why you continue to tell people how good hunting is in Colorado when all averages for rifle seasons point to a hunter killing an elk every 5 years. I'm just curious. I would venture to guess Utah, Montana, and Wyoming have higher successes in general season and draw hunts even with different regions being spike only in UT. I would take Montana hands down to Colorado with a 3 month combined archery and rifle season. The main shortcoming with Colorado is the short seasons, which makes it tough to pattern a bull before the season ends or he is bumped onto private land.
I have never kept it any secret that we were one of the shows CDOW/CPW worked with for promotion of their non-resident hunting opportunities. Our deal with CPW ended with the deer hunt we did last year. We do not have a contract to do any promo work with them this year.
Does that change my mind about the fun elk hunting I have in Colorado? Nope.
I am going on an OTC elk hunt again this year, with no involvement from CPW. I have that much fun doing it. And, I want other people to understand how much opportunity exists and the fact that they will kill an elk if they get after it, maybe invest a couple years learning an area, and even with the number of hunters, the hunt is worth the price and time it takes.
I hunt every western state for elk. In the elk hunter's dream world, where tag availability and cost are not an issue, given me a tag in AZ, central MT, NM, and NV every year. Have never hunted UT, so I can't opine on that one. That dream world scenario is a lot different than CO OTC, in most all respects.
In the scope of what I deal with, I am trying to show options for hunters who don't need/want elaborate point schemes, want to go every year, want to know when they will get to go, have tighter budgets, and have lots of public land to hunt. That is why CO OTC elk is so appealing to many, including me.
I understand your comments of the values you see in other states with different seasons structures. Just a few problems with what you point out in some of those states - getting a tag in Utah and Wyoming. Yeah, they have higher success rates, but they cost a lot more money and require a lot more time and investment in licenses and points to get a tag. Not really talking equals between these two states and CO. I would check your stats about the UT general tags having success rates above CO.
Montana bull elk success rates on the general rifle tags would be comparable to the OTC units I often talk about in CO. Usually in the mid-teens in MT general units, higher in limited units.
I would take MT general over CO OTC, also, given that I live here and I like to archery hunt elk. Cost and tag availability for me is heavily weighted to MT in that scenario. If I was a travelling non-resident I would have to look at the price difference. If I was not an archery hunter, I would look at MT being a far greater archery elk hunt, compared to the rifle elk hunts.
Hope that answers your question. I have been hunting Colorado for many different species, since 2003. I think CO is a very good option for many species, not just the OTC elk hunts I talk about.
I have drawn deer tags in CO units that have taken one to two points that were as good of hunts as I have had in supposed "top units" in other states. CO offers the best mix of deer quality and opportunity of any state I hunt.
They also offer the greatest elk opportunity of any state I hunt, even if quality is not superb. I bet most guys who have never shot a bull would be happy with a four-point bull, overjoyed with a five point, and ecstatic with a six point. All of those are possible in Colorado OTC hunts, without years of time and money invested in elaborate point schemes. Our OTC elk episodes are directed at those same guys I speak of.
I suspect you will see me hunting CO OTC for the rest of my elk hunting years, with one exception. I have CO 17 elk points. In the coming years I will be trying to use them for a limited entry tag, and following that will be back in the OTC hunts.
This year, I went so far as to apply for another PP, and second choice being a unit with left over cow tags last year, in hopes I will get one this year. A cow tag would be a great tag to go with an OTC bull tag. These hunts are not only fun, but make for good hunts in the idea of our TV show. We try to have four to five OTC or easy-to-draw hunts in the show, rather than all premium hunts that take years to draw.
Hope that answers your question. I understand what you are saying about some other states and hope I have made a case for why I promote CO OTC elk hunts and will continue to do so, even without an promo agreement with CPW.
And none of that changes my opinion that boycotting Colorado over the gun issues is a short-sighted, and bad, idea. Doing so is a classic "feel good" point that does nothing to hurt those doing the stupid things and only serves to hurt those who I think are good folks.
And none of that changes my feeling that the new CO landowner tag legislation is a bad idea. Oak mentioned a ton of reasons why that is bad for the self-guided hunter, and I agree with all of them.