380 Tag Reduction

Stone_Ice_1

Well-known member
Joined
Apr 23, 2014
Messages
456
Location
Helena, MT

After having the tag two years ago I would be a big supporter of this. Most people get this tag once if they are lucky and my experience was that it mostly wasn't worth the 20 year wait to get the tag for the quality of bulls I saw.
 
Can't get past the paywall but can read the snippet.

This is pretty disheartening. As someone that lives in Townsend and I have countless friends that have never drawn. Everyone I talk to that has drawn, and seeing the tooth envelopes come through, it's still a much better unit for bulls than any general unit in the state. Compared to a true trophy unit in likely any other state I'm sure it comes well short. 350" bull there is probably about getting a 300" bull in a general unit in Montana, doable but no where near a "good chance" for most hunters. Realistically most of the "big" bulls I've seen come out of there are in the 320" range but I don't think that is the median or average, probably closer to 300" but a general unit is probably 260-270" median/average?

It's probably easier for you to support this, but for those that haven't drawn it may create more distrust in FWP as the statewide trend seems to be lower trophy size animals and lower hunter satisfaction across the state.

I'm glad to see FWP make an active management decision based on the herd and age data and hope this move corrects the issue, but question how we got to this point and if poaching is truly causing the herd to decline I would like to see more done to mitigate that and increase the penalty for such actions. I don't think our trophy restitution has been updated to 2026 $US values.
 
I do agree with the spikes. Probably the only state that has one of their premier elk tags districts allow over the counter shooting of spikes. If they didn't shoot the spikes they could probably keep the tag numbers the same or even increase them after a few years.

Another issue is, last I looked there were 100 tags given out. But it is actually closer to 115. I discovered when I had the tag that many landowners were double dipping to get additional tags. They of course apply for the tag through the landowner program. These tags count toward the 100 for the district. However they also have the program (I can't remember the name of it) where the landowner allows a hunter access to their property to hunt in exchange for a bull or sometimes cow tags. At least one of these landowners is also using that same land in the Block Management Program. I was excited that I had "won" the lottery to one of these areas that are exchanged for tags and then found out the area I "Won" was in block management and anybody could hunt it already. Anyway, my point is there are about 12 or so of these tags given out that are on top of the 100 done by the draw.
 
I do agree with the spikes. Probably the only state that has one of their premier elk tags districts allow over the counter shooting of spikes. If they didn't shoot the spikes they could probably keep the tag numbers the same or even increase them after a few years.
We certainly do it here in WA.
 
We shoot the heck out of spikes in some good draw areas in Idaho also
 
But it is actually closer to 115. I discovered when I had the tag that many landowners were double dipping to get additional tags.
Oh - the paid advocates aka lobbyists - love those gamey dumpy systems.

Go look at the "thousands of elk" lines that get peddled in the legislature by the sponsored liars.

They are a complete and total joke, and most working landowners that are actually busy working their land dont have the time or energy to look into the best way to manipulate the system.
 
There’s a collar study Going on in the districts to the west where I live -335 and 318. The biologist has a theory, and I believe it is correct, that a fair amount of elk have left 380 for the other side of I 15.

The Elkhorns are a fantastic district. Many of the elk that are there are accessible on public land, and there’s a plethora of private land owners that allow access. I support the reduction in permit tags, not because I wish it to be so, but because the tooth data as well as the elk numbers justify it.

I think the current state of Wapati in that range is chiefly the result of three things - increasingly poor habitat in the core of the range due to beetle kill and lack of land management at scale(though they try), year-round human activity that increases every year(bikes, hikers, four wheeling, camping, etc. ) and hammering both cows and spikes for the last couple decades. I think we can fairly quickly control the last of those things. Some changes were made to reduce the cow harvest in this most recent season setting, and I would love to see Spike harvest severely reduced by way of a shortened season or stopped altogether. What you will hear the professionals say, and in my experience they say this every time a more restrictive direction is asked for anywhere, is: “well then where is that hunting pressure going to go?”. I don’t think it’s an invalid or unsound question, but I am kind ok with the answer of, “ somewhere else”. Damn near every district around it is over objective anyway.
 
I don’t pay much attention to 380 simply because I think it’s historically overrated but it would make a lot of sense to me to eliminate spike harvest in that unit along with this reduction.

Keeping a high bull to cow ratio seems common sense to managing a unit intended to be a premier trophy unit. Control the population with cow licenses. There’s no need to allow spike harvest in that unit especially since it’s in close proximity to other units that allow brow tined bull or anterless harvest on a general tag and is in close proximity to Butte and Bozeman and sees a significant amount of pressure from those population centers.
 
It’s pretty simple why they have to reduce tags. About five years ago, they opened up much of the district to over-the-counter cow elk tags. I believe Forest Service land was excluded, but most of the remaining land was opened up to over-the-counter cow hunting.

You can’t harvest a bunch of cows year after year and expect to maintain good bull hunting. We’ve seen the same thing happen in the 600 districts.

It was really disappointing to see how many hunters were too selfish to support Wargo’s amendment, which would have limited hunters to harvesting one elk per year on public land. That would have been a step in the right direction.

Until Montana hunters are willing to look beyond their own immediate opportunities and prioritize the long-term health of the elk herds and quality of hunting, we aren't going to see much change.

339 will have the same issue in 5 years and FWP will come saying we need to reduce tags there too and then say it's a habitat issue.....
 

Forum statistics

Threads
120,526
Messages
2,262,638
Members
39,138
Latest member
BigScheib
Back
Top