Whitetail score guess
- Thread starter Randy11
- Start date
spook12
New member
You think there's a muley in the wood pile?
trevore
New member
Looks like a muley to me. No eye guards and no throat patch. Did you see his tail?
He and his momma must be a little confused. Hanging out with a muley, no brows, and forked G2's.... Maybe mom liked exotic guys?
mid 140's gross. Crazy thing is he looks like a really young deer with his short nose. Did you get a look at his tail? You said "these deer" the other buck is a muley for sure
mid 140's gross. Crazy thing is he looks like a really young deer with his short nose. Did you get a look at his tail? You said "these deer" the other buck is a muley for sure
Last edited:
Mudranger1
Well-known member
- Joined
- Jun 30, 2010
- Messages
- 2,986
glad I'm not going crazy...was wondering what he was seeing that I wasn't
JohnCushman
Well-known member
I'm guessing muley too
tarheel
Well-known member
Without a doubt!!
Score
So randy got me to wondering ... this whitey actually looks a bit like what randy tried to fool us with. Does someone mind taking a guess at the score? I wont be able to confirm till it gets back from the taxi, but am curious to know.
http://onyourownadventures.com/hunttalk/showthread.php?t=248980
So randy got me to wondering ... this whitey actually looks a bit like what randy tried to fool us with. Does someone mind taking a guess at the score? I wont be able to confirm till it gets back from the taxi, but am curious to know.
http://onyourownadventures.com/hunttalk/showthread.php?t=248980
That thing is such a pig. I've got a 72 inch shed sitting here that looks smaller than that guy. I'd guess 162-165.
fowladdict
Well-known member
- Joined
- Aug 20, 2005
- Messages
- 2,591
I figured you were just being funny.
I don't see his ears being 22 inches wide. I know that is kind of the norm for a mature buck, but I killed a buck in NM that was 19 inches tip to tip. He looked much wider than he is becuase he is almost three inches wider than his ears on both sides and he is a hair wider than 24 inches. I'm going to guess this buck is about 26 to 27 inches wide. Maybe someone else will disagree with me on the ears, but to me they just don't look that wide.
Hopefully this is a buck you have an opportunity to go after, he is a dandy.
I don't see his ears being 22 inches wide. I know that is kind of the norm for a mature buck, but I killed a buck in NM that was 19 inches tip to tip. He looked much wider than he is becuase he is almost three inches wider than his ears on both sides and he is a hair wider than 24 inches. I'm going to guess this buck is about 26 to 27 inches wide. Maybe someone else will disagree with me on the ears, but to me they just don't look that wide.
Hopefully this is a buck you have an opportunity to go after, he is a dandy.
You could very well be right. His body looks big but his head and ears really don't.
I'm basing my numbers off of his ears being 20-21 inches.
JohnCushman
Well-known member
Is he on land that you can hunt him?
L. I. Yankee
New member
Im saying low150...no g1's and very light on mass....he is still in velvet and is not impressive in the mass dept but he has good main beam length...IMO its a tough one to score....Id say shoot him and let the taxidermist score him.....
My Dad has 2 on the wall around that size.
His missing eye guards and mass I think isn't what you think it is I think he may hit 160 to 165 but that is assuming he gets a main beam of 24 inches to give him 24 inside spread. Without that he is under 160 more like 150 - 158.
His missing eye guards and mass I think isn't what you think it is I think he may hit 160 to 165 but that is assuming he gets a main beam of 24 inches to give him 24 inside spread. Without that he is under 160 more like 150 - 158.
CabinFever
Member
Is this the kind of joke like the ones where a rancher's horse gets shot by a hunter he gave access to, when the hunter thought it was an elk? Or the moose seemingly every year getting mistaken for elk in CO? Or maybe its just the guy with pictures of a Muley on a baited trail cam, and asking what the whitetail scores...
Cctaxidermy
New member
He look like a mule deer to me. Could have a little whitetail in him though since his ears are a little bit shorter than most. I would guess he scores around 150"
