Snuck out to the range today with a clean barrel. I can confirm that
@JLS was correct, as he occasionally seems to be.
Clean barrel shot 100% on par with the previously dirty barrel. So similarly that I couldn't differentiate Sunday's target from today's, had I not labeled them. Spent some time re-zeroing and it's shooting well again. (It was also 1.5" right, but that was less concerning that the elevation issues)
I've never had a scope become unreliable without a memorable explanation, until now. I must have bumped it pretty good somewhere along the way. Being that this is a "backup" gun, perhaps I wrote something off that I shouldn't have. Can't recall.
The quasi unidentifiable debris situation didn't help my sanity in this situation. I'll be looking into the above mentioned guides or finding a piece of non-reactive tubing to replace the one that is supplied with the Tipton guide.
Lastly, I had fully expected that
@ImBillT was on to something with his "months in the safe copper fowling" philosophy, but that wasn't the case here. I do however appreciate the detailed input from Bill. And the interwebs were no help in defining the "graphite fowling" comment that was redacted. Perhaps that one will remain over my head for a while.