JJ, I didnt mean to infer that you didnt know about bear hunting. It is just the picture you painted" having a nice laugh and taking photos of a bear in a tree", to me, does not describe the hound adventure accurately.It is the same thing that I have heard from many hunters that have never hunted with hounds. You are talking about pulling the trigger only ,I believe. Yes, I do believe that my clients want to kill bears. I also believe that ,as far as the hunter is concerned, that bait hunting would be alot easier than a hound hunt.
I dont see any difference in the "hunt" as far as pulling the trigger goes. I dont believe it takes any more of a hunter to sit on his butt in a treestand than it does to sneak into a treed bear. On a guided hunt the bait site was selected ,pre baited, and the stand erected without any help from the hunter. If the skill involved is keeping the stand from creaking I would even that up with the pressure of a pack of dogs barking in your ear while making a shot.
I think that most clients just want their bear and dont have the time or money to do it on their own. that is where a guide comes in. I know I really want to take a mountain lion this winter. I also know that I will have to go with someone that cat hunts out west. I dont know how I could go out west blind and take one with my own dogs and equipment. I will still feel very happy if I take a lion even if I have to have some help to do it. I think that is the way most clients of mine feel with their bears.JJ,being a former houndsman, you know I will have to have at least one of my dogs at the tree though.LOL
As far as being the most successful way to take a bear is with hounds.You may be right on a one to one basis. Many of the bait guides here take 20 hunters a week. They will probably average 15 bears. The ratio is probably higher with hounds but you are limited to one or 2 hunters per week. I think if you figured out man days hunting to game killed it would still favor dogs but not by much. In the state of N.H. last year we had a total of 449 bears killed. Of those 37 were with dogs !!!
I guess I have kind of rambled here. The point I was trying to make is I dont think ,in the overall picture, a bear with dogs is any easier a hunt than a baited one.
JJ, do you know a guide from Washington ,near Spokane, named Ron Warren ???