Although synthetics showed up in the 1960's in was not until Weatherby came out with the Fibermark in the 1980's that it really took off and every manufacturer jumped on board. By that time I had been hunting for 40 years, and to me they ( synthetics ) did not feel ( or look ) right.
I have always preferred quality over quantity, so my preference was to have a few really nice ones that FIT me. I am guessing but I would bet in my adult years I have done 90% of my hunting with only 4 different caliber rifles and one shotgun. My husband on the other hand wanted every caliber and action, but he also preferred wood, but he was even older than I was. It was what we knew.
. Fit is so important. That was why I liked the four rifles and one shotgun, they were all made to fit me, "Fit" is important to both sexes but possibly even a bit more so for females. Hunting Wife found a shotgun that fit and worked for her. If its not broke dont fix it.
I will guarantee you that Hunting Wife and I could hunt all day and then have dinner together while sharing stories of our family and past hunting adventures, while sipping some of her home made wine and listening to some Sinatra tunes without either of us caring about what each others shotguns cost.
________________
short answer: Wood for me