CWD Briefing to WY Game and Fish Commission

I worked in Cody 13 years ago doing that CWD sampling. From my memory it was pretty rare to be putting down symptomatic animals back then. Hearing that it isn't uncommon now is sobering.
 
Meateater also had a whole episode of their podcast talking with an expert on CWD: https://youtu.be

What is sobering to me is the head-in-the-sand hunters who don't know anything about CWD. I maybe shouldn't be surprised given the anti-intellectualism that seems to have taken off in the past ~6 years.
Pretending to know stuff is easier if everyone knows nothing.
 
There were a lot of great CWD topics covered in that meeting. Also, some great questions.

There is no surprise that CWD prevalence is higher in and around Ag fields where deer congregate and spend time in close proximity. It's alarming to see CWD suffering deer. I haven't seen one deer with CWD symptoms, and I am in the field every day working on winter range where CWD was first discovered on the Front Range in Northern Colorado back in the 1970's. Maybe things are different here for some reason?

CWD prions have been building in the soil in this area for 40 to 50 years. There never has been a catastrophic die-off like the CPW's predictions back in the 1980's. In fact, Colo was re-writing the B&C record books back in the 1980's and 1990's with CWD present. This was prior to when the CPW came up with the scenario of harvesting older age class bucks by enacting late rifle rut seasons and increasing harvest quotas. The herds did fine for several decades before late rut rifle season dates and increase in tag quotas were put into place even with CWD present. B&C entries from Colo have dropped close to 0 after several 5 year plans went into effect offering rifle rut seasons and higher tag quotas...which had little to nothing to do with CWD.

My thought is that survival of the fittest is a key component for CWD management. This currently is not considered as a CWD management strategy. The only management strategy I've heard is to harvest more bucks and decrease the population of deer.

If you think about it, the best genetics in the herd are mature bucks and does that live through disease, harsh winters, drought, predators, etc. Killing off old age class bucks that possibly have CWD resistant alleles that build slowly over time doesn't seem right. Predators are pretty well known to kill the sick and weak. Unhealthy deer are more prone to dying from drought and extremely tough winters. This in fact, is what has happened for centuries in Colo prior to the conception of rut rifle dates and increase in tag allotments.

The commissioner's meeting in Wyo documented CWD increased prevalence in units with agriculture (more or less alfalfa fields where deer concentrate). That is not earth-shattering news. There was a lot of good information in the WG&F meeting, but I still believe it's not worth slaughtering herds and older age class bucks. If CWD prions already exist in the soil, it's too late to do much to prevent it's spread...it's already there and prions will remain in the soil for years. All the surrounding units in Wyo likely already have CWD prions so killing off deer isn't going to prevent the spread and may actually do more harm in the long run than good. From what I've seen living in the CWD red-zone in Colorado, let nature take its course. This is totally contrary to what the WG&F likely requests. Reducing already low mule deer populations is asking for even more dramatic declines after drought and winterkill years. Also, the best genetics in herds may be sacrificed.

CWD has been in Colorado since the 1960's or 70's. It's been around 50+ years without 1 documented catastrophic die-off even in the face of ag properties where there is a higher concentration of deer. There are more catastrophic losses of localized deer and antelope herds from EHD and biologists don't blink an eye nor try to figure out ways to combat that disease that can totally wipe out localized big game populations.

A prime example of survival of the fittest system currently at work in Colorado is the Rocky Mtn Arsenal and Rocky Mtn Nlt Park deer herds where CWD has been around since the 1980's, There is no hunting in these fairly large areas and there are gigantic monster muley bucks presently roaming the hills. The mule deer populations aren't booming but they also have never severely declined. Taking a look at internet photos and videos of whopper bucks found recently roaming both of those locations brings back flashbacks of what it used to be like all over Colorado.

There has never been a catastrophic die-off even though there hasn't been a hunting season on those 2 large parcels of land. The deer on the Arsenal are confined and concentrated behind a tall fence and those deer are doing just fine even though CWD was found inside the fence back in the 1980's. The deer in RMNP and around Estes are another prime example of deer that are doing just fine where no hunting is allowed. The predators, winterkill etc kill the sick and weak. There are mature bucks in both locations that live relatively long healthy lives. I often wonder if mature bucks in those 2 locations have CWD resistant alleles....which is another subject that most biologists don't consider. I noticed this was never mentioned in the WG&F commissioners meeting.

There is no need to have a "the sky is falling down" attitude with CWD. I certainly hope Wyoming learns from Colorado's mistakes! From my travels around Wyoming, there are several things that could greatly improve mule deer populations across the state that have nothing to do with CWD.
 
Last edited:

Latest posts

Forum statistics

Threads
120,546
Messages
2,263,367
Members
39,141
Latest member
GarciaBoy
Back
Top