I shot a good sized cow this year and my buddy and I split the load equally. 1/2 in his 2200 and 1/2 in my 2800. We did the same thing last year as well. We have also hauled out around 12 deer with them and no problems whatsoever!
It might be a good idea to hear the facts before visually indicting the guy. It looks like there is still some velvet on the antlers which could explain the light color of the rack.