I am with corn king on the eye guards, fist think I noticed, Second was the drivers side G2 like WNC2500 said. Biggest difference is the additional tine on the passenger side, but extra tines happen, It is always better to look for similarity than to focus on a few differences. I think it is a very good chance it is the same buck.
I know a deer is a deer but I think he even carries his body in the same lazy posture and the head and face are just too much the same to me also. I’m even more convinced the more I look at him.
Is the OP going to give us the answer or maybe he doesn’t know.