I would take the muley if he was heavy beamed as you say. Both would be awesome trophies, but I would think the odds are better that I would have an opportunity at a 350 B&C bull before the type muley you describe.
Added the pictures, hope you enjoy!
Hyperlink to B&C Score Sheet
http://users.ev1.net/~sodolak/Hunting/Elk/Pictures/Dad_s_330_Bull/Dad_s_Elk_Score_Sheet/dad_s_elk_score_sheet.html
[This message has been edited by TexasHunter (edited 01-17-2001).]
We (my father and I) had booked an elk hunt for the 2nd week in October 1999 in New Mexico with an outfitter in May 1998. It seemed like 1998 would never end and then 1999 finally came. Every conversation we had for the year somehow centered around our pending elk hunt. During April, my...