I used to go to St Augustine fairly regularly, unfortunately it's been several years now. If you had shrimp at O'Steen's while you were there, I'm really going to be jealous.
I used to have a Leupold Vari XII high gloss that was a popular scope back then, but I sold that scope several years ago. The Weaver or some of the Leupolds from back then would be great choices.
Back in March we hosted our annual Barrel Burner match, sponsored by MDT. Originally our match was in July, but shooting when the temps hit 113* is too hot. March was much cooler, and I think people preferred the early spring timing. These matches are part of the Precision Rifle Series. We had...
Congratulations!
I'm guessing on those real windy days that not only is it tougher making the shot, but that the carp don't spend as much time with their backs sticking up out of the water. How big were the bigger fish?
I picked the S&W. It's probably more like picking a good pair of boots though, there are lots of good choices, but it comes down to personal 'fit' and preference. I haven't shot any of the Colts, but a few of the Rugers and S&W. For me the S&W just had a fit & feel I preferred.